Brooks Buford Suspicious Package Found

Posted on
Brooks Buford Suspicious Package Found Rating: 10,0/10 4729 reviews

The search warrant was short and succinct, dated August 3, 9:41 a.m. F.B.I. special agent Diader Rosario was instructed to produce 'hair samples (twenty-five pulled [#image: /photos/54cc00ef44a199085e8992d3]and twenty-five combed hairs from the head)' of Richard Allensworth Jewell. That Saturday, Atlanta was humid; the temperature would rise to 85 degrees. There were 34 Olympic events scheduled, including women's team handball, but Richard Jewell was in his mother's apartment playing Defender on a computer set up in the spare bedroom. Jewell hadn't slept at all the night before, or the night before that. He could hear the noise from the throng of reporters massed on the hill outside the small apartment in the suburbs. All morning long, he had been focused on the screen, trying to score off 'the little guy who goes back and forth shooting the aliens,' but at 12:30 the sound of the telephone disturbed his concentration. Very few people had his new number, by necessity unlisted. Since the F.B.I. had singled him out as the Olympic Park bombing suspect three days earlier, Jewell had received approximately l,000 calls a day—someone had posted his mother's home number on the Internet.

Brooks Buford, after the group's initial separation, went on to record several projects, Straight Outta Rehab, which was never released due to Artista going out of business. He is currently working on a follow-up album titled 'Suspicious Package' as well as a side project with Ashley Alan-Lee and Tommy Henriksen called The Audio Club.

'I'll be right over,' his lawyer Watson Bryant told him. 'They want your hair, they want your palm prints, and they want something called a voice exemplar—the goddamn bastards.' The curtains were drawn in the pastel apartment filled with his mother's crafts and samplers; a home without a dog is just a house, one read. By this time Bryant had a system. He would call Jewell from his car phone so that the door could be unlatched and Bryant could avoid the questions from the phalanx of reporters on the hill.

Turning into the parking lot in a white Explorer, Bryant could see sound trucks parked up and down Buford Highway. The middle-class neighborhood of apartment complexes and shopping centers was near the DeKalb Peachtree Airport, where local millionaires kept their private planes. The moment Bryant got out of his car, the reporters began to shout: 'Hey, Watson, do they have the murderer?' 'Are they arresting Jewell?' Bryant moved quickly toward the staircase to the Jewells' apartment. He wore a baseball cap, khaki shorts, and a frayed Brooks Brothers polo shirt. He was 45 years old, with strong features and thinning hair, a southern preppy from a country-club family. Bryant had a stern demeanor lightened by a contrarian's sense of the absurd. He was often distracted—from time to time he would miss his exits on the highway—and he had the regional tendency of defining himself by explaining what he was not. 'I am not a Democrat, because they want your money. I am not a Republican, because they take your rights away,' he told me soon after I met him. Bryant can talk your ear off about the Bill of Rights, ending with a flourish: 'I think everyone ought to have the right to be stupid. I am a Libertarian.'

At the time Richard Jewell was named as a suspect by the F.B.I., Watson Bryant made a modest living by doing real estate closings in the suburbs, but Jewell and his lawyer had formed an unusual friendship a decade earlier, when Jewell worked as a mailroom clerk at a federal disaster-relief agency where Bryant practiced law. Jewell was then a stocky kid without a father, who had trained as an auto mechanic but dreamed of being a policeman; Bryant had always had a soft spot for oddballs and strays, a personality quirk which annoyed his then wife no end.

The serendipity of this friendship, an alliance particularly southern in its eccentricity, would bring Watson Bryant to the immense task of attempting to save Richard Jewell from the murky quagmire of a national terrorism case. The simple fact was that Bryant had no qualifications for the job. He had no legal staff except for his assistant, Nadya Light, no contacts in the press, and no history in Washington. He was the opposite of media-savvy; he rarely read the papers and never watched the nightly news, preferring the Discovery Channel's shows on dog psychology. Now that Richard Jewell was his client, he had entered a zone of worldwide media hysteria fraught with potential peril. Jewell suspected that his pickup truck had been flown in a C-130 transport plane to the F.B.I. unit at Quantico in Virginia, and Bryant worried that his friend would be arrested any minute. Worse, Bryant knew that he had nothing going for him, no levers anywhere. His only asset was his personality; he had the bravado and profane hyperbole of a southern rich boy, but he was in way over his head.

For hours that Saturday, Bryant and Jewell sat and waited for the F.B.I. From time to time Jewell would put binoculars under the drawn curtain in his mother's bedroom to peer at the reporters on the hill. Bryant was nervous that Jewell's mother, Bobi, would return from baby-sitting and see her son having hairs pulled out of his head. Bryant stalked around the apartment complaining about the F.B.I. 'The sons of bitches did not show up until three p.m.,' he later recalled, and when they did, there were five of them. The F.B.I. medic was tall and muscular and wore rubber gloves. He asked Jewell to sit at a small round table in the living room, where his mother puts her holiday-theme displays. Bryant stood by the sofa next to a portrait of Jewell in his Habersham County deputy's uniform. He watched the F.B.I. procedure carefully. The medic, who had huge hands, used tiny drugstore tweezers. 'He eyeballed his scalp and took his hair in sections. First he ran a comb through it, and then he took these hairs and plucked them out one by one.'

Jewell 'went stone-cold,' but Bryant could not contain his temper. 'I am his lawyer. I know you can have this, I know you have a search warrant, but I tell you this: If you were doing this to me, you would have to fight me. You would have to beat the shit out of me,' Bryant recalled telling the case agent Ed Bazar. Bazar, Bryant later said, was apologetic. 'He seemed almost embarrassed to be there.' As he counted out the hairs, he placed them in an envelope. The irony of the situation was not lost on Bryant. He was a lawyer, an officer of the court, but he had a disdain for authority, and he was representing a former deputy who read the Georgia law code for fun in his spare time.

It took 10 minutes to pluck Jewell's thick auburn hair. Then the F.B.I. agents led him into the kitchen and took his palm prints on the table. 'That took 30 minutes, and they got ink all over the table,' Bryant said. Then Bazar told Bryant they wanted Jewell to sit on the sofa and say into the telephone, 'There is a bomb in Centennial Park. You have 30 minutes.' That was the message given by the 911 caller on the night of the bombing. He was to repeat the message 12 times. Bryant saw the possibility of phony evidence and of his client's going to jail. 'I said, 'I am not sure about this. Maybe you can do this, maybe you can't, but you are not doing this today.'

All afternoon, Jewell was strangely quiet. He had a sophisticated knowledge of police work and believed, he later said, 'they must have had some evidence if they wanted my hair.… I knew their game was intimidation. That is why they brought five agents instead of two.' He felt 'violated and humiliated,' he told me, but he was passive, even docile, through Bryant's outburst. He thought of the bombing victims—Alice Hawthorne, the 44-year-old mother from Albany, Georgia, at the park with her stepdaughter; Melih Uzunyol, the Turkish cameraman who died of a heart attack; the more than 100 people taken to area hospitals, some of whom were his friends. 'I kept thinking, These guys think I did this. These guys were accusing me of murder. This was the biggest case in the nation and the world. If they could pin it on me, they were going to put me in the electric chair.'

I met Richard Jewell three months later, on October 28, a few hours before a press conference called by his lawyers to allow Jewell to speak publicly for the first time since the F.B.I. had cleared him. Jewell's lawyers also intended to announce that they would file damage suits against NBC and The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. It was a Monday, and that weekend the local U.S. attorney had delivered a letter to one of the lawyers stating Jewell was no longer a suspect. 'Goddamn it,' Bryant had told me on the phone, 'the sons of bitches did not even have the decency to address it to Richard Jewell.'

I had been instructed to come early to the offices of Wood & Grant, the flashy plaintiff lawyers Bryant had pulled in to help him with Jewell's civil suits. When I arrived, I was alone in the office with Sharon Anderson, the redheaded assistant answering the phones. 'Wood & Grant … Wood & Grant … Wood & Grant'—the calls overwhelmed her. Lin Wood and Wayne Grant were rushing from CNN to the local NBC and ABC affiliates, working the shows. 'Everyone has theories of who the real bomber is,' Sharon said. 'I just write it all down and give it to the boys.'

When Lin Wood arrived, he was still in full makeup. Movie-star handsome with green eyes and styled hair, Wood has the heated oratory of a trial lawyer. 'It's a war! Why in this bevy of stories does not anyone point out the fact that Richard was a hero one day and a demon the next? They have destroyed this man's life!'

Watson Bryant had worked with Wood and Grant years before in a local law firm. He admired Wayne Grant for his methodical sense of detail; Grant, a New Yorker, had once forced the city of Atlanta to pay large damages to a man injured while illegally digging for antique bottles in a park. But Lin Wood's suppressed rage was a marvel to Bryant. 'He is so tough he could make people cry in depositions when we were kids,' Bryant told me. Wood possessed the smooth style of a member of the Atlanta establishment, but he had a hardscrabble past. He was a boy from 'the wrong side of the tracks' in Macon who at age 17 discovered his mother's body after his father had murdered her. His father went to jail, and Wood wound up as a lawyer. He went through college and law school on scholarships and with part-time jobs. I could hear Wood on Sharon's telephone: 'He's more than innocent. He's a goddamn hero.… Everyone is going to pay who wronged Richard Jewell. Besides NBC and The A.J.C., we are going to look into suing CNN and Jay Leno.'

Through the large picture window, I had a clear view of the remains of the Centennial Olympic Park, where the bomb had exploded on the night of July 26. Where the sound-and-light tower had once been, there was now a flattened dirt field. It was possible to see the Greek commemorative sculpture that Richard Jewell used to describe for tourists at the AT&T pavilion, where he worked as a security guard.

Suddenly, Jewell was in the room. 'Hi. I'm Richard. I'm a little late. I don't want you to think I am rude. I am not like that.' He had an open face, a bland pleasantness, an eagerness to please. 'Can I get you a Coke?' he asked me. 'How about some coffee?' Jewell wore a blue-and-white striped shirt and chinos. He occupied physical space like a teenager; he sprawled, he lumbered, he pawed through Sharon's candy bowl. On TV his face had a porcine blankness; he appeared suspicious. In person, Jewell has a hard time disguising his emotions.

We were alone in the conference room; I noticed that Jewell avoided looking out the window toward the park. He shifted his glance nervously away from the view. He often awakens in the middle of the night, drenched in sweat, thinking of the events in the park in the early morning hours of July 27. 'It took me days before I could even come in here,' he said anxiously.

When Jewell noticed a local ABC reporter outside near Sharon's desk, his face darkened. 'I don't want to be around reporters right now. I guess I am a little nervous. What is he doing here?' The atmosphere was now filled with tension; the reporter was escorted out.

Moments later, we gathered in the hallway. Wood was steely: 'We are going in two cars. Richard, you drive with me. Your mother will go with Wayne. As we walk down the hall right now, if the ABC people are outside, I will tap you on the shoulder and I will say, 'How are you doing?' You will say, 'Fine.' Is that understood?' 'O.K., Lin. I understand,' Jewell said quietly, head bowed.

As Jewell walked down the hall, an ABC cameraman photographed him looking grim. Seconds after the elevator doors closed, Jewell exploded: 'What are they doing here, Lin? Did you invite them? They are animals. Why didn't you get them out of here?'

'ABC has been good to you. How do I get them out of the office on the day of your press conference?'

'That is what security is for!' Jewell said, quivering with rage. 'Where is Watson?' he asked in the garage. 'I told you: he's at a real-estate closing. He will meet you at the press conference,' Wood said. Jewell moved to his mother's side, as solicitous as a child. 'Are you all right, Mother?' he asked. 'It is all I am going to be able to do not to do something!' she said angrily.

When we arrived at the Marriott hotel on I-75, there was another discussion in the parking lot, about who would walk with whom in front of the cameras. Jewell turned to his close friend Dave Dutchess: 'Are you all right, man?' Dutchess, a truckdriver who worked with Jewell years ago, has long hair and a tattoo of a panther on his forearm. 'Richard and I are like brothers,' he told me. 'I would die for him.' As the cameras closed in on them, the group fled to a private room in the Marriott. The auditorium was filled with reporters. 'Showtime! Showtime!' the cameramen yelled when Jewell, his mother, and all the lawyers took the stage.

'I hope and pray that no one else is ever subjected to the pain and the ordeal that I have gone through,' Jewell said, his voice breaking. 'The authorities should keep in mind the rights of the citizens. I thank God it is ended and that you now know what I have known all along: I am an innocent man.'

After the press conference, Bobi and Richard Jewell remained in a private room. The bookers from Good Morning America and the Today show pressed Jewell to step before their cameras, and when Watson Bryant told them no, Monica, the G.M.A. booker, began to cry, 'I'll lose my job.' Then Yael, the Today-show booker, cornered Nadya Light: 'Is Richard doing something with G.M.A.?'

Upstairs, Jewell and his mother were being filmed by a CBS camera crew for a 60 Minutes news update. 'Well, Bobi, did you get your Tupperware back?' Mike Wallace asked by phone from New York. 'Richard, you need to lose some more weight.' Despite Wallace's festive spirit, the atmosphere was curiously flat. Bryant urged Jewell to talk to a USA Today reporter. Jewell balked: 'They can all go suck wind.'

In the car on the way back to Wood & Grant, Bobi was angry. All of her possessions had come back from the F.B.I. marked up with ink. 'Every piece of Tupperware I own is ruined, thank you very much. They wrote numbers all over it, and I have tried everything to clean it—Comet and Brillo—but nothing works.'

Back at the office, she sat on the sofa and listened as Bryant negotiated with Yael for a flight to New York—Delta, first-class, 9:30 p.m. Jewell was scheduled to appear on three shows in New York, visit the American Museum of Natural History, and then fly to Washington, D.C., for Larry King Live. 'I would like to go home, put on my outfit, and walk in the woods,' Bobi said. 'Richard, we are leaving.'

'Yes, ma'am,' Richard said.

One hour later, a telephone call came in to the offices of Wood & Grant. The lawyers had the call on speaker, and it blared through the room. 'Goddamn it, Lin. When will this be over?' In the background, you could hear Bobi sobbing. 'What in the world?' Wood asked. Jewell explained that a sound truck from ABC had been waiting in the parking lot when the Jewells got home. There had been words and threats, and Dave Dutchess had taken his stun gun off his motorcycle and waved it at the ABC van. The cameraman yelled: Stop harassing us! Dave yelled back: You are harassing us! Now get your ass out of here!

Wood shouted into the speakerphone: 'Do not meddle! You cannot jeopardize where you have gotten to and what you want to do! All you have to do is put up with this for one more day and the damn thing is over. Bobi, there is nothing you can do about it; you have to stay cool.' Bobi cried back, 'They are going to destroy me!'

The moment they hung up, Wood turned to Bryant. 'New York is canceled. No Katie Couric. No Good Morning America. They are losing it. You better call Yael.' 'No,' Bryant said, 'they have lost it. All of the above: their patience, their temper and heart.'

That evening a very testy Katie Couric tracked Bryant down at Nadya Light's apartment, where we had gone to watch the news. 'I want you to know that I canceled interviewing Barbra Streisand in L.A. for Richard Jewell. Don't think he is always going to be a news story. No one will care about him in three days,' she said, according to Bryant. 'Look, Katie, I am sorry. But Richard is in no condition to talk to the press. He is worn out,' Bryant told her.

Later, Jewell would tell me that that day, which should have been one of his most satisfying, was actually his worst. His notoriety had tainted the triumph; everything positive had become negative. 'I was in despair,' he said. As he had for most of the previous 88 days, he spent the night confined in the Buford Highway apartment, a prisoner of his circumstances, with his mother, Dave Dutchess, and Dave's fiancée, Beatty, eating Domino's Pizza and watching himself lead the newscasts on NBC, CBS, and ABC.

‘This case has everything—the F.B.I., the press, the violation of the Bill of Rights, from the First to the Sixth Amendment,' Watson Bryant told me in one of our first conversations. It has become common to characterize the F.B.I.'s investigation of Richard Jewell as the epitome of false accusation. The phrase 'the Jewell syndrome,' a rush to judgment, has entered the language of newsrooms and First Amendment forums. On the night of Jewell's press conference, a commentator on CNN's Crossfire compared Jewell's situation to 'Kafka in Prague.' The case became an investigative catastrophe, which laid bare long-simmering resentments of many F.B.I. career professionals regarding the micromanagement style and imperious attitude of Louis Freeh and his inner circle of former New York prosecutors, who have worked together since their days at the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Southern District. Within the bureau, the beleaguered director now has a new nickname: J. Edgar Hoover with children. Like Freeh, those near him have also acquired a nickname: Louie's yes-men. Two of Freeh's closest associates, F.B.I. general counsel Howard Shapiro and former deputy director Larry Potts, have been severely criticized, respectively, for advising the White House of confidential F.B.I. material and for an alleged cover-up of the mishandling of the 1992 standoff at Ruby Ridge, where F.B.I. agents killed the wife and son of Randy Weaver, a white supremacist.

In November and December, the Office of Professional Responsibility conducted an exhaustive investigation into the Jewell affair. Responding to an attempt by headquarters and certain officials to distance themselves, according to F.B.I. sources, several agents, including a senior F.B.I. supervisor in Atlanta, have provided the O.P.R. with signed statements insisting that Freeh himself was responsible for 'oversight' during the crisis. These agents 'shocked the investigators' because they reiterated, when asked who was in charge of the overall command of the investigation, that it was the director himself.

What happened to Richard Jewell raises an important question central to Freeh's future tenure: in the midst of a media frenzy, does the F.B.I. have any responsibility to protect the privacy of an innocent man? Over the last year, this concept was broached with Bob Bucknam, Louis Freeh's chief of staff. During the long Pizza Connection trial in the 1980s, it was Bucknam who handed Freeh files at the prosecutor's table. According to highly placed sources in the bureau, Bucknam's answer was immediate: the F.B.I. has no responsibility to correct information in the public domain.

Richard Jewell had a reverence for authority that blinded him to the paradox of his situation. He idealized the investigative skills of the F.B.I. and could not understand that he had become ensnared in a web fraught with the weaknesses of a self-protective bureaucracy. Pennsylvania senator Arlen Specter has invited Jewell to Washington to testify at congressional hearings on the F.B.I.'s conduct in the Atlanta bombing. Ironically, the bungling of the investigation might lead to the reshuffling of personalities at the top of the bureau and threaten Freeh's reputation. In October, according to The Washington Post, Freeh sent an unusual memo to all 25,000 F.B.I. personnel: He would not be abandoning his post amid reports of problems with the Jewell case and Filegate, and of a growing dissatisfaction inside the bureau. 'I am proud to be the F.B.I. director,' Freeh wrote.

From the beginning, Jewell was perceived in the public imagination as a hapless dummy, a plodding misfit, a Forrest Gump. On one of the first days he worked as a security guard at the AT&T pavilion, he noticed that his co-workers were covering the steps inside the sound tower with graffiti. On one step Jewell scrawled with a flourish two bromides: if you didn't go past me, you are not supposed to be here and life is tough. tougher when you are stupid. Soon after he was targeted as a suspect in the Olympics bombing, the F.B.I. confiscated the step. Analysts appeared to believe that the graffiti contained a clue to his character. 'They told the lawyers the statement was an obvious taunt,' Jewell said. In fact, the second line was an expression he had cribbed from one of his favorite actors, John Wayne.

'To understand Richard Jewell, you have to be aware that he is a cop. He talks like a cop and thinks like a cop,' his criminal lawyer, Jack Martin, told me. The tone of Jewell's voice drops noticeably when he says the word 'officer,' and his conversation is filled with observations about traffic patterns, security devices, and car wrecks. Even the vocabulary he uses to describe the 88 days he was a suspect is out of the lexicon of police work, and he continues to talk about his situation then in the present tense: 'This is an out-and-out ambush, and I am a hostage.'

Jewell has a need to accommodate. He can be startlingly opaque. On the afternoon of July 30, Jewell answered the door of his mother's apartment to Don Johnson and Diader Rosario from the F.B.I. 'We need your help making a training film,' they told him. 'I never questioned it,' he told me. The next day Rosario appeared again with a search warrant. 'The weird thing was that when they were searching my apartment I was, like, 'Take everything. Take the carpet. I am law enforcement. I am just like you. Guys, take whatever you are going to take, because it is going to prove that I didn't do anything.' And a couple of them were looking at me like I was crazy.'

Leaving the apartment on one occasion, he told the agents, 'I am wearing a bright shirt so y'all can see me easier.' He recalled feeling anger when he read descriptions of himself as a child-man, a mama's boy, and 'a wannabe policeman,' but he said, 'If I was in the place of everybody else and I saw a 34-year-old guy living with his mother, I would have reservations about that, too. I would think, Why is he doing that?'

The December issue of Atlanta magazine reported that there was no record of a Jewell family in Danville, Virginia, where Richard Jewell was born. Atlanta referred to an article in the Danville Register & Bee which asked, 'Did Richard Jewell ever sleep here?' 'This is a part of my life Richard and I do not like to speak about,' Bobi Jewell told me one night at dinner. Richard was born in Danville, but his name was Richard White; his father was Bobi's first husband, Robert Earl White, who worked for Chevrolet. According to Bobi, Richard's father, who died recently, was 'irresponsible and a ladies' man.' When Richard was four, the marriage broke up. Bobi found work as an insurance-agency claims coordinator and soon met John Jewell, an executive in the same business. Shortly after John Jewell married Bobi, he adopted Richard.

From the time Richard was a child, he and his mother were a unit. Bobi, a woman of intelligence and disciplined work habits, is both tender and tough on the subject of her son. She still calls Richard 'my boy,' but she has a peppery disposition. Richard was brought up in a strict Baptist home. 'If I didn't say 'Yes, ma'am' or 'No, ma'am' and get it out quick enough, I would be on the ground,' he said. When he was six, the family moved to Atlanta. Richard was the boy who helped the teachers and worked as a school crossing guard, but he had few friends in high school. 'I was a wannabe athlete, but I wasn't good enough,' he said. He ran the movie projector in the library. A military-history buff, he liked to talk about Napoleon and the Vietnam War and read books on both World Wars.

Jewell's ambition was to work on cars, so he enrolled in a technical school in southern Georgia. On his third day there, Bobi discovered that her husband had packed a suitcase. 'He left a note saying that he was a failure and no good for us,' Jewell said. Almost immediately, Richard moved back home and took a job repairing cars. 'My mom and I tried to take care of each other,' he said. 'I think I handled it pretty much better than she did.' Richard took the brunt of his father's abandonment; Bobi pulled even closer to her son. 'She hated all men for about three years after that, and she became overly protective of me. She looked at it that I was going to do the same thing that my dad did. I was 18 or 19. I was working. She never liked my dates, but I never held that against her. We have always been able to lean on each other.'

Richard managed a local TCBY yogurt shop and once stopped a burglary in progress. At the age of 22, he was hired as a clerk at the Small Business Administration, and he impressed Watson Bryant and the other lawyers in the office with his personable nature. They called him Radar because of his efficiency. 'You could say, 'I'm hungry,' and suddenly this kid would be by your side with a Snickers bar,' Bryant recalled. When Jewell's contract with the S.B.A. ran out, he moved on to be a Marriott house detective. In 1990 he was hired as a jailer in the Habersham County Sheriff's Office, and in 1991 he became a deputy. As part of his training, he was sent to the Northeast Georgia Police Academy, where he finished in the upper 25 percent of his class. He finally had an identity; he was a law-enforcement officer.

Jewell was unlucky in love. He presented one woman with an engagement ring, and later, in Habersham County, he would give another a large wooden key with a sign that read, this is the key to unlock your heart, but both relationships came apart. In northern Georgia, Jewell worked nights and became wedded to his job. By his own description, he was methodical. 'I am the kind of person who plans everything. I like to go from A to B to C to D. This going from A to D and arguing over everything—I say no.' Habersham County, a scenic part of the piney woods in Georgia's Bible Belt, was for Jewell like 'leaving the 1990s and going into the 1970s in terms of law enforcement.' Many rich Atlantans have country houses in the mountains, but the small towns of Demorest and Charlottesville are relatively undeveloped, reminding one of Jewell's lawyers of the scenery in the movie Deliverance. 'If you get lost up there, you might find a guy with a bow and arrow,' the lawyer said.

Recently, Jewell and I took the 90-minute drive from Atlanta to Habersham County, which has acres of apple orchards. The leaves were turning, and the roads were mostly deserted. In the towns, however, were stores, apple stands, and even a good Chinese restaurant. As Jewell's blue pickup truck turned into the parking lot of a shopping center, several people came out to greet him.

Jewell had lived in a small yellow house up a steep rocky driveway. On the day we visited, the current resident's Halloween decorations were still up, as were faded white satin ribbons hanging from many trees, remnants of a campaign to clear Richard Jewell organized by area friends. Jewell had lived 50 yards from the Chattahoochee River near a kayak-and-canoe tourist concession on a main road—not in a 'cabin in the woods,' as several reports stated after the bombing. He worked the night shift, and when he would arrive home at dawn, he told me, he could look up and 'see a sky filled with stars.'

He was not a loner; he made friends with several local families. He would often leave a box of Dunkin' Donuts on friends' porches at four a.m. During the O. J. Simpson trial, he and the other deputies would meet in the turnaround on Highway 985 in the middle of the night and review the day's events and the bungling by the Los Angeles Police Department. Jewell would later be annoyed that the F.B.I. confiscated his copy of former prosecutor Vincent Bugliosi's account of the trial. Jewell dated a local girl, Sheree Chastain, and had a close relationship with her family.

Jewell had a complex history working at the Habersham County Sheriff's Office. When he was still a jailer, he arrested a couple making too much noise in a hot tub at an apartment building where he did part-time security work. He was arrested for impersonating an officer and, after pleading guilty to a lesser charge, was placed on probation on the condition that he seek psychological counseling.

By his own estimation, Jewell's strength as a cop was 'working car wrecks.' He had his mother's diligence; he worked 14 hours a day and organized a safety fair. Later in 1995 he wrecked his patrol car and was demoted to working in the jail. Rick Moore, a local deputy, advised him to accept the job, but Jewell despised the jailhouse atmosphere. He told me, 'It was a small room filled with cigarette smoke. I couldn't take it.' He resigned, and in a short time he moved to a police job at Piedmont College, a liberal-arts school with approximately 1,000 students on the main road in Demorest. The college police had jurisdiction only on campus and in an area extending out 500 feet. Jewell chased cars speeding down the highway and had arguments over turf with other officers. He was instrumental in several arrests, including that of a suspected burglar he discovered hiding at the top of a tree. For his work on a volunteer rescue squad, he was named a citizen of the year.

According to Brad Mattear, a former resident director, Piedmont was a school of 'P.K.'s'—preachers' kids. It was 80 percent Baptist with a strict no-drinking rule. The college had many rebellious students, according to Mattear, kids who were 'away from home for the first time and wanted to party and drink.' Mattear knew Jewell well and recalled his good manners and playful nature. 'It was always 'Yes, sir' and 'Yes, ma'am.' Jewell would tell students, 'I know y'all are going to drink. Don't do it on campus.'

Jewell felt confined by his boundaries and could be heavy-handed when it came to writing out reports on minor infractions. Once when we were driving by the campus, he pointed to a small brick dormitory. 'That was where all the partying would go on,' he told me. Jewell would raid dorm rooms and report drinking violations. 'I did not hesitate to tell the parents—in no uncertain terms—what their kids were up to,' he said.

He soon made enemies at the school. 'Three or four times a week,' Mattear said, Piedmont students were in the office of Ray Cleere, the president of the college, complaining about Jewell and other Piedmont police. After Jewell was admonished for a number of controversial arrests, he resigned.

Jewell had an out: his mother was going to have an operation on her foot. He would go home to Atlanta for the Olympics and look for a new job. He called his mother: 'Is it all right with you if I stay with you while you have your surgery?' He hoped he might get a job with the Atlanta police or, failing that, work security at the Olympics. 'I thought, Working at the Centennial Olympic Park will look really good on my résumé.'

At the age of 33, back in his mother's apartment, he was at first treated like a wayward teenager. Bobi was sharp with him about his slovenly habits, his weight, and his driving. Bobi had carved out a life for herself; she arrived at work by eight a.m. each morning and had many friends. Trim, with short-cropped hair, Bobi Jewell is the kind of woman who labels her clothes and spices and spends much of her spare time baking cakes and baby-sitting for extra money. She carries on telephone friendships with claim adjusters at other companies. It was somewhat unsettling for her, she told me, to have Richard at home after she had grown used to living with only her dog, Brandi, and her cat, Boots. Bobi was annoyed that he had wrecked a patrol car, and worried about his safety. 'Every time he leaves the apartment, I'll say, 'Richard … ' And he'll say, 'Yes, ma'am. I know. The person that I am going to see will be there when I get there,' she said. On one occasion Bobi talked about Richard's return to Atlanta. 'What is wrong with trying to revamp your life?' she asked me. Her eyes filled with tears. 'Why does everyone in the media think it is so strange?'

On Friday, July 26, Bobi Jewell was home waiting for her niece to arrive from Virginia for the Olympic softball competition the following week. In preparation, she had stocked her apartment with food. It was a clear Georgia evening, not as hot as had been expected. As usual, Richard left for the park at 4:45 p.m. and arrived at the AT&T pavilion about 5:30. His stomach was bothering him; he was convinced that he had eaten a bad hamburger the day before. Lin Wood and Wayne Grant had arranged to take their children to Centennial Park that night. The park, in downtown Atlanta, stretches over 21 acres. There were air-conditioned tents, concerts on the stage, and hot-dog and souvenir stands. Downtown Atlanta was usually deserted in the oppressively hot, humid summer, but this year thousands of tourists filled the sidewalks, or sat on benches in the shade of some crape-myrtle trees, or cooled off by a fountain. Tour buses clogged the main arteries, and everyone complained that it took hours to get anywhere; stories were traded about athletes' getting to their competitions late because of the poor planning of the Atlanta Committee for the Olympic Games.

As always, Jewell was working the 12-hour night shift near the sound-and-light tower by the stage. He was pleased because one of his favorite groups—Jack Mack and the Heart Attack—was going to perform at 12:45. Jewell had a routine: he would check in and fill the ice chest he kept by a bench at his station. Jewell liked to offer water and Cokes to pregnant women or policemen who stopped to rest.

After he arrived at the park, his stomach cramps grew worse and he had a bout of diarrhea. At approximately 10 p.m. he took a break to go to the bathroom. The closest one was by the stage, but the security staff was not allowed to use it. 'I really have to go,' Jewell says he told the stage manager. 'And he said, 'Well, O.K. this time.'

When Jewell came out, he noticed that it was 'real calm' and there wasn't much wind blowing. At that time of night, the crowd from Bud World became a little more raucous. Jewell was annoyed when he saw a group of drunks near his bench and beer cans littering the area beside the fence nearby. As he went to report the trash and the group that was carousing, he spotted a large olive-green military-style backpack, known as an Alice pack, under the bench. There had been a similar bag found the week before. Jewell later told an F.B.I. agent that he was annoyed that one of the drunks had tried to get into the lens of a camera crew. Jewell had told them to cut it out. 'They were running off at the mouth,' Jewell would later tell Larry Landers of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation (G.B.I.).

'I was light about the package at first,' he told me, 'kidding around with Tom Davis from the G.B.I.: 'Well, are you going to open it?' At that point, it was not a concern. I was thinking to myself, Well, I am sure one of these people left it on the ground. When Davis came back and said, 'Nobody said it was theirs,' that is when the little hairs on the back of my head began to stand up. I thought, Uh-oh. This is not good.

'I never really had time to be frightened. My law-enforcement background paid off here. What went through my head was like a computer screen of this list I had to do. I had to call my supervisor. I have to tell people in the tower that something was going on. I have to be firm with them, stay calm, and be professional.'

Almost immediately, Jewell and Tom Davis cleared a 25-foot-square area around the backpack; Jewell made two trips into the tower to warn the technicians. 'I want y'all out now. This is serious.'

Two blocks away on Marietta Street, approximately 300 editors, copywriters, and reporters from Cox newspapers around the country had taken over the extra desks in the new eighth-floor newsroom at The Atlanta Journal-Constitution to prepare the special Olympics edition they put out each afternoon. The paper had gone 'Olympics-crazy,' according to one reporter. The editor, Ron Martin, and the managing editor, John Walter—'Wal-Mart,' as they were called—had let it be known that no expense would be spared. Ann Hardie, who normally covers science, had been sent around the world to master the fine points of beach volleyball; Bill Rankin, officially on the federal-court beat, was assigned table tennis. The paper intended to set new standards in its hometown during the games, but in addition there was a hint of redemption in the air.

Since Cox newspaper executives had forced the resignation of the distinguished editor Bill Kovach in 1988, the paper had suffered a severe loss of reputation. 'We all felt just kind of beaten down,' one reporter said. Kovach had been brought to Atlanta from The New York Times to elevate The A.J.C. into being the definitive paper of the New South, but eventually he irritated the local powers. Atlanta was inbred, a city of deals, and he resigned in a blaze of press outrage. Kovach now ran the Nieman journalism-fellowship program at Harvard, and the movie rights to his turbulent years in Atlanta—reported in these pages by Peter J. Boyer—had been sold to Warner Bros.

Within the profession, The A.J.C. had become something of a joke. More and more, its emphasis was on what John Walter called 'chunklets'—short bits in a soft-news style known as eye-candy. The paper published features on couples massage and how mushrooms grow in the rain. Walter had fired off several terse memos to ensure that there would be no more jumps of news stories to back pages and no more unsourced news stories, except on rare occasions. 'I don't see any reason why you can't report hard news in a short form,' one editor told me.

The A.J.C. style of reporting in declarative sentences had a name, too: the voice of God. It was omniscient, because it allowed no references to unattributed sources. Subjects such as aids, which often required confidentiality, could not be covered properly in the paper, in the opinion of several reporters. The A.J.C. picked up news stories with unnamed sources from The New York Times, however, and reporters groused about the hypocrisy of the double standard.

On Saturday morning, July 27, Bob Johnson, the night metro editor, left the newsroom at one a.m. The sidewalks were still crowded; Johnson sat on a wall outside waiting for an A.J.C. shuttle bus to pick him up. About 1:25 he heard a strange noise. 'It sounded like an aerial bomb at a fireworks show,' he said. He recalled thinking, Damn, that is sort of foolish. Then he heard screams and saw people running. Johnson rushed back upstairs to the almost deserted sixth-floor newsroom. Lyda Longa, a night police reporter, was still there. Johnson sent her down to the park and turned on the news, but nothing had moved across the wires. Just after two a.m., Longa called from the park. She told Johnson that one person had been killed and dozens were down—it was absolute chaos. Johnson could hear the sirens and the screams through the telephone; he began to type into his computer. 'We were trying to get a bullet into the street edition,' Johnson recalled. In the crisis, it took only minutes for reporters to return to the newsroom; several had been at the park when the bomb went off. Rochelle Bozman, an Olympics editor, appeared and took over for Johnson. Soon John Walter was there, as was Bert Roughton, who would assist him in supervising the A.J.C. coverage of the bombing.

At the park, Jewell spoke with the first F.B.I. agents to arrive on the scene. The smell and the noise, he remembered, were overwhelming, and sensations blurred together. 'It was hard to describe the sound,' he said. 'It was like what you hear in the movies. It was, like, kaboom. I had seen an explosion in police training. We had ear protection when it went off. It smelled like a flash-bang grenade. The sky was not filled with black smoke, but grayish-white. All the shrapnel that was inside the package kept flying around, and some of the people got hit from the bench and some with metal.'

Bobi Jewell had just gone to sleep when the telephone rang. It was Richard. 'Mom, they had a bomb go off down here, but I am O.K. regardless of what the TV says.' He could hardly speak; he seemed paralyzed. Jewell did not mention to his mother that he had found the knapsack and alerted Tom Davis. Bobi was perplexed. 'I thought, What does he mean?' All night long she stayed on the foldout sofa watching the news reports. She was frightened by the ambulances, the noise, the bodies in the park.

Soon veteran homicide detectives in the Atlanta police arrived at the bomb site. One sergeant was trying to make his way through the crowd when an Olympics official stopped him. 'Tell these cops to get the hell out of here,' he said, according to a captain in the homicide division. 'Well, you get the fuck out of here. Who are you?' the sergeant demanded. Agents from the Atlanta F.B.I. office and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms were in a shouting match over jurisdiction. 'We are handling this!' one said. 'No, this is ours!' an F.B.I. agent snapped.

In the command center at F.B.I. headquarters in northeastern Atlanta, there was complete pandemonium. The Olympics were a national convention for law enforcement. Some 30,000 security personnel were on hand. Over the next few days, there would be an internal debate: Who was going to be in charge of the bombing investigation? In Atlanta at that time were three veteran investigators with executive experience: Tom Fuentes, who is credited with helping to bring John Gotti to heel; Barry Mawn, who has worked extensively in organized-crime probes; and Robin Montgomery, the head of the critical-incident unit at Quantico, who at Ruby Ridge in 1992 questioned the disastrous 'rules of engagement' which led to tragedy.

In the early-morning hours, F.B.I. agents picked up several suspects, including one referred to as 'the drunk in the bar.' According to F.B.I. sources, Louis Freeh himself got on the telephone to Barry Mawn. Freeh, a former F.B.I. agent, was personally monitoring the initial investigation by means of a series of conference calls from the command post at F.B.I. headquarters. He focused on 'the drunk in the bar,' who had been making threats the night before, and within hours the information was leaked that the F.B.I. had a suspect. From Atlanta, Barry Mawn contacted his superiors in Washington. 'This suspect is not the bomber,' he reportedly said, according to a former high-level F.B.I. executive. Freeh allegedly lost his temper and belittled Mawn's professional abilities. He is said to have told Mawn that he 'had handled this all wrong.' The words one hears characterizing Freeh's telephone calls to the agents on duty in Atlanta are 'abusive,' 'condescending,' and 'dismissive.' A story went around the command center that Freeh was already saying, 'We have our man,' according to a source in the bureau.

Freeh made a decision: however experienced Montgomery, Fuentes, and Mawn were, this investigation would be run by Division 5 of the F.B.I., the National Security Division, a former counterintelligence unit that has been looking for a purpose since the Cold War ended. Trained in observation, division members rarely made a criminal case—their strength was intimidation and manipulation rather than the deliberate gathering of evidence to be presented in court. The F.B.I. promptly declared the bombing a terrorism case and placed it under the authority of Bob Bryant, head of the division. David Tubbs of Division 5 was sent to Atlanta to be the spokesman and to augment Woody Johnson, the Atlanta special agent in charge (S.A.C.), who had been trained in hostage rescue and who was awkward in press briefings. Tubbs was not as experienced in criminal cases as Mawn or Montgomery, who returned to Newark and Quantico, respectively, 'to get out of the line of fire,' according to numerous F.B.I. sources. But Bryant and Freeh were reportedly micromanaging the S.A.C.'s and, later, the case agents Don Johnson and Diader Rosario.

On the morning of the bombing, Watson Bryant's alarm went off at six a.m. He was going to the Olympic kayak competition on the Ocoee River with Andy Currie, a friend from his Vanderbilt University days. He learned of the bombing on the radio as he was getting ready to go to Currie's house. 'Whoever has done this should be skinned alive,' he told Currie. He spent the day in the country, and on Sunday he went out to run errands. When he got home, there was a message on his answering machine: 'Watson, this is Richard Jewell. You may have heard that I found the bomb and people are calling me a hero. Somebody told me I might get a book contract.' It had been years since Bryant had spoken to Jewell, but he did not immediately return the call; he was busy finishing up some contracts so that he could take a few days off to enjoy the Olympics.

In addition, Bryant was annoyed with Jewell. After Bryant had befriended him in their days at the Small Business Administration, Jewell had borrowed his new, $250 radar detector and never returned it. He had promised to pay him $100 for it, but he never had. In the meantime, Bryant's life had changed; he had set up an office as a solo practitioner. Bryant despised corporate politics and had no gift for them. His penchant for taking on pro-bono work for friends annoyed his wife, however. Bryant believed that Richard Jewell had attached himself to him years earlier because he lacked a father, but nevertheless Jewell could get on his nerves. By the summer of 1996, Bryant was preoccupied; his marriage had come apart two years earlier, and he was trying to sort out his life.

When he finally returned Jewell's phone call, he said, 'Well, damn it, where's my $100?' Jewell laughed uneasily and told him about discovering the green backpack that contained the bomb. 'Didn't you see me on the news?' Bryant reminded him that he rarely watched TV. 'I am proud of you, Richard,' he said. 'About this book contract, I think it's far-fetched, but don't sign anything unless I see it first.'

In the Newsweek cover story detailing the bombing, published Monday, July 29, there was no mention of Richard Jewell. It said only that 'a security guard' had alerted Tom Davis of the G.B.I. that no one had claimed the backpack under his bench. By the time Newsweek was on the stands, however, Jewell had been interviewed on CNN. The AT&T publicity department had booked him on TV and told him to wear the shirt with the AT&T logo. Jewell reluctantly agreed. 'The idea of going on TV made me nervous,' he told me. 'I was not the hero. There were so many others who saved lives.'

In Demorest, Ray Cleere, the president of Piedmont College, was home on Saturday, July 27, watching CNN. Cleere had at one time been Mississippi's commissioner of higher education, but he was now posted at the rural Baptist mountain school. He was said to feel that he had suffered a loss of status in the boondocks, where he was out of the academic mainstream. He called Dick Martin, his chief of campus police. Shouldn't they call the F.B.I. and tell them about Richard Jewell? he asked. Cleere had had a strong disagreement with Jewell when one of the students was caught smoking pot. Jewell wanted to arrest him; Cleere said no. Cleere, Brad Mattear recalled, 'worried constantly about the image of the college.' According to Mattear, 'Cleere loved the limelight. He wanted public attention'—the very trait he reportedly ascribed to Richard Jewell.

Dick Martin, who was fond of Jewell, suggested a compromise, according to Lin Wood: he would call a friend in the G.B.I. Cleere then called the F.B.I. hot line in Washington himself. Wood says Cleere later complained that no one had seemed to want to listen to what he had to say about Richard Jewell. But his telephone call would trigger a complex set of circumstances in Habersham County, where F.B.I. investigators fanned out over the hills, attempting to uncover evidence that could lead to Jewell's arrest. 'The F.B.I. took his word, and what it actually did was get them both in a bunch of trouble,' Mattear said. (Cleere has declined to comment.)

For Richard Jewell, Tuesday, July 30, would become a haze in which his life was turned upside down. 'The hours of the day ran so fast it is hard to remember what all happened,' he told me. He started the day early at the Atlanta studio of the Today show. He was tired; the evening before he had had his friend Tim Attaway, a G.B.I. agent, for dinner. He had made lasagna and had drawn Attaway a diagram of the sound-and-light tower. Jewell had talked into the night about the bombing; only later would he learn that Attaway was wearing a wire.

Suspicious

Despite the late evening, Jewell was excited at the thought of meeting Katie Couric and being interviewed about finding the Alice pack in the park. His mother asked him to try to get Tom Brokaw's autograph. 'He was a man my mom respected a great deal,' he said.

When he got back to the apartment, he was surprised to see a cluster of reporters in the parking lot. 'Do you think you are a suspect?' one asked. Jewell laughed. 'I know they'll investigate anyone who was at the park that night,' he said. 'That includes you-all too.' Jewell did not turn on the TV, but he noticed that the group outside the door continued to grow. At four that afternoon, Jewell received a phone call from Anthony Davis, the head of the security company Jewell worked for at AT&T. 'Have you seen the news?' Davis asked. 'They are saying you are a suspect.' Jewell said, 'They are talking to everybody.' According to Jewell, Davis said, 'They are zeroing in on you. To keep the publicity down, don't go to work.'

Within minutes, Don Johnson and Diader Rosario knocked on Jewell's door. They exuded sincerity, Jewell recalled. 'They told me they wanted me to come with them to headquarters to help them make a training film to be used at Quantico,' he said. Johnson played to Jewell's pride. Despite the reporters in the parking lot and the call from Anthony Davis, Jewell had no doubt that they were telling the truth. He drove the short distance to F.B.I. headquarters in Buckhead in his own truck, but he noticed that four cars were following him. 'The press is on us,' Jewell told Johnson when they arrived. 'No, those are our guys,' Johnson told him. This tactic would continue through the next 88 days and be severely criticized: Why would you have an armada of surveillance vehicles stacked up on a suspected bomber?

It was then that Jewell started to wonder why he was at the F.B.I., but he followed Johnson and Rosario inside. Rosario was known for his skills as a negotiator; he had once helped calm a riot of Cuban prisoners in Atlanta. Johnson, however, had a reputation for overreaching. In Albany, New York, in 1987, he had pursued an investigation of then mayor Thomas Whalen. According to Whalen, the local U.S. attorney found no evidence to support Johnson's assertions and issued a letter to Whalen exonerating him completely, but Whalen believed it cost him an appointment as a federal judge.

As Jewell sat in a small office, he wondered why the cameraman recording the interview was staring at him so intently. After an hour, Johnson was called out of the room. When he returned, he said to Jewell, 'Let's pretend that none of this happened. You are going to come in and start over, and by the way, we want you to fill out this waiver of rights.'

'At that moment a million things were going through my head,' Jewell told me. 'You don't give anyone a waiver of rights unless they are being investigated. I said, 'I need to contact my attorney,' and then all of a sudden it was an instant change. 'What do you need to contact your attorney for? You didn't do anything. We thought you were a hero. Is there something you want to tell us about?' Jewell grew increasingly apprehensive and later recalled thinking, These guys think I did this.

When the agents took a break, Jewell asked to use the phone. 'I called Watson four times. I called his brother. I told his parents that I had to get hold of Watson—it was urgent. I was, like, 'I have to speak to him right now.' What was going on was that Washington was on the phone with Atlanta. The people in Washington were giving them questions.' Jewell said he knew this because the videotapes in the cameras were two hours long and 'Johnson and Rosario would leave every 30 minutes, like they had to speak on the phone.' The O.P.R. report, however, would assert that no one at headquarters knew about the videotaping or the training-film ruse. Lying to get a statement out of a suspect is, in fact, not illegal, but clearly Johnson and Rosario were not making decisions on their own. Even the procedure of having a fleet of cars follow a suspect was an intimidation tactic used by the F.B.I. Later, according to Jewell, Johnson and Rosario would both tell him privately that they believed he was innocent, but that the investigation was being run by the 'highest levels in Washington.'

Within the bureau, the belief is that during one of the telephone calls Freeh instructed Johnson and Rosario to read Jewell his Miranda rights. Freeh is said to have learned of Johnson's history from a member of his security detail, who had worked in Atlanta. He told Freeh that 'Johnson had a reputation for being obnoxious and a problem.' In addition, a week after Jewell's interview, Freeh reportedly received a call from Janet Reno, who had learned about the ruse from Kent Alexander, the local U.S. attorney, and Deputy Attorney General Jamie Gorelick. Freeh wondered aloud how it was that, of all the agents in Atlanta, Johnson had been selected to work on the Jewell case. Like Jewell, Johnson had wound up in Atlanta because of his overzealous behavior—according to an F.B.I. source, the Whalen episode had resulted in a 'loss-of-effectiveness transfer,' an F.B.I. euphemism. (Johnson declined to respond.)

On that same Tuesday, Watson Bryant and Nadya Light closed the office early and went to Centennial Park. Light, 35, a pretty Russian immigrant, had never met Radar, Bryant's old friend, and wanted to buy him a celebratory meal. Killing time until Jewell came on duty, they went into the House of Blues and then bought some hot sauce. Walking toward his car, Bryant saw newsboys hawking the afternoon edition of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. 'It was like out of a cartoon. They were all yelling!' he recalled. 'I caught the headline out of the corner of my eye.' The headline read: fbi suspects 'hero' guard may have planted bomb.

Bryant borrowed 50 cents from Light to buy the paper and began to read: 'Richard Jewell, 33 … fits the profile of the lone bomber.' I could not believe it.'

At that moment, Bryant's brother, Bruce, who was on his way to the diving competition, got a call from Jewell. 'Where is Watson?' As Bruce Bryant walked past a Speedo billboard with a TV screen, he saw Richard Jewell's face filling the screen. 'Oh, my God,' he said to his wife. At the same moment, Watson was in his car a block away on Northside Drive when he too noticed the Speedo screen. He could not get back to his house—the streets were blocked off for the cycling competition. From his car he called F.B.I. headquarters and demanded to speak to Jewell. 'He is not here,' the operator said. From his home phone, he picked up his messages and heard Jewell's low, urgent tones. 'He didn't leave a number,' Bryant told Light. 'Call Star 69,' she said. The number came back: 679-9000, the number for F.B.I. headquarters, which he had just dialed. Within minutes, Bryant had Jewell on the phone. Jewell told him he was making a training film. 'You idiot! You are a suspect. Get your ass out of there now!' Bryant told him.

Before The Atlanta Journal-Constitution broke the story of Richard Jewell, there had been a debate in the newsroom over whether or not to name him. One block away, CNN's Art Harris and Henry Schuster had alerted the network's president that Jewell was targeted, but they held the story, because they understood its potential magnitude. At The A.J.C., Kathy Scruggs, a police reporter, who had allegedly gotten a tip from a close friend in the F.B.I., got a confirmation from someone in the Atlanta police. According to the managing editor, John Walter, the first edition of the paper that Tuesday had a brief profile of Jewell. It was dropped in later editions as Walter questioned whether the paper had enough facts to support the scoop. Because of the voice-of-God style, the paper ended up making a flat-out statement: 'Richard Jewell … fits the profile of the lone bomber.'

When I asked John Walter about the lone-bomber sentence, he said, 'I ultimately edited it.… One of the tests we put to the material is, is it a verifiable fact?' One editor added, 'The whole story is voice-of-God.… Because we see this event taking place, the need to attribute it to sources—F.B.I. or law enforcement—is less than if there is no public acknowledgment.' John Walter indicated that he had not seen a lone-bomber profile. I asked him, 'Whose profile of a lone bomber does Richard Jewell fit? Where is the 'says who' in this sentence?' Walter said that he felt comfortable with the assertion.

The page-one story had a double byline: Kathy Scruggs and Ron Martz. Walter had told these two early on that they would be the reporters assigned to any Olympic catastrophe. Martz, who had covered the Gulf War, had been assigned the security beat for the Olympics; Scruggs routinely covered local crime. Scruggs had good contacts in the Atlanta police, and she was tough. She was characterized as 'a police groupie' by one former staff member. 'Kathy has a hard edge that some people find offensive,' one of her editors told me, but he praised her skills. Police reporters are often 'dictation pads' for local law enforcement; recently the American Journalism Review sharply criticized The A.J.C. for the scanty confirmation and lack of skepticism in its coverage of Jewell.

Brooks Buford Suspicious Package Found In Chicago

The newsroom atmosphere resembled that at F.B.I. headquarters; there was a frenzy to be first. Kent Walker, a newsroom intern, published a story in the same edition, with a glaring mistake in the headline: bomb suspect had sought limelight, press interviews. Since Ray Cleere's tip to the F.B.I., the 'hero bomber' theory had been circulating among Atlanta law-enforcement officers. Maria Elena Fernandez, a reporter, was sent to Habersham County on July 29. By coincidence, William Rathburn, the head of security for the Olympics, had been at the Los Angeles Olympics in 1984 when a fake bomb was found on a bus—left by a policeman who sought attention.

On the surface, the story had an irresistible newsroom logic: Jewell was clearly looking for recognition. Bert Roughton, the city editor, had answered the telephone when a representative from AT&T called to ask if the paper would like a Jewell interview. According to Walter, Roughton himself typed a sentence in the Scruggs-and-Martz piece: 'He [Jewell] also has approached newspapers, including The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, seeking publicity for his actions.' But he hadn't. Walter explained, 'There was nothing wrong with that sentence. That's journalistically proper. It is not common practice, to my knowledge, to ask someone you are interviewing … 'Are you here of your own free will?' Jewell had not contacted the paper—a fact which would have been easy enough to check. Walter became snappish when I described the sentence as 'a mistake.' 'It was not a mistake,' he said angrily. Scruggs and Martz quoted Piedmont College president Ray Cleere as backup. According to Cleere, Jewell had been 'a little erratic' and 'almost too excitable.'

There was no doubt raised by The A.J.C. about the value of Cleere's information or the fragility of the F.B.I.'s potential case. On Tuesday morning, July 30, Christina Headrick, a young intern on the paper, was sent to Buford Highway to stake out Richard Jewell's apartment. She phoned in that there were men doing surveillance. By deadline, John Walter had made a decision: he would tear up the afternoon Olympics edition and lead with Jewell.

Several states away, Colonel Robert Ressler was watching CNN when the A.J.C. extra edition was shown. Ressler, who was retired from the behavioral-science unit of the F.B.I., had, along with John Douglas, developed the concept of criminal-personality profiling. He was the co-author of the Crime Classification Manual, which is used by the F.B.I. He had interviewed Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, and John Wayne Gacy, and as he watched the TV report, he was mystified. 'They were talking about an F.B.I. profile of a hero bomber, and I thought, What F.B.I. profile? It rather surprised me.' According to Ressler, the definition of 'hero homicide'—a person looking for recognition without an intent to kill—perhaps emerged as 'hero bomber.' 'There is no such classification as the hero bomber,' he told me recently. 'This was a myth.' Later he said, 'It occurred to me that there was no database of any bomber who lived with his mother, was a security guard and unmarried. How many hero bombers had we ever encountered? Only one that I know of, in Los Angeles, and his bomb did not go off.' Ressler knew that something was off; profiles are developed from a complex set of evidence and facts derived only in part from a crime scene. The bomb had been deadly, which was not consistent with the 'hero complex.' Furthermore, he wondered, where did they get the information to put the profile together that fast? He asked himself, What came first here, the chicken or the egg? Was the so-called profile actually developed from the circumstances, or was it invented for Richard Jewell?

When Jewell returned home from F.B.I. headquarters just before eight p.m., NBC was showing special Olympic coverage. He sat on the sofa and watched Tom Brokaw say, 'They probably have enough to arrest him right now, probably enough to prosecute him, but you always want to have enough to convict him as well. There are still holes in this case.'

Jewell knew that Brokaw was his mother's favorite newsman; he looked at her and noticed 'the color and the blood flow out of her face when she heard that.' Bobi turned to him and asked, 'What is he talking about?' Jewell later recalled, 'Brokaw was talking about her son as a murderer.… She started crying, and what am I going to say to her? 'Mom, Watson is going to fix this'? What do you say? She doesn't hear anything anyway—she was in hysterics.' At that point, Jewell said, he broke down as well.

The day Watson Bryant inadvertently became the lead lawyer for Richard Jewell, he was an attorney whom almost no one in the Atlanta legal establishment had ever heard of. 'Who the hell is Watson Bryant?' a caption in the daily legal sheet, the Fulton County Daily Report, would read after he had appeared on the Today show. Bryant understood Jewell's vulnerability and decided on a strategy: he would treat him as a member of his own family. In Atlanta, the Bryants were a clan: Watson's father, Goble Bryant, had been a West Point tackle, on the 1949 college all-star team; his grandfather had invented a process for putting handles on paper bags. Watson had partied through Vanderbilt University and had barely gotten accepted to law school at the University of South Carolina. He had a close relationship with his brother, Bruce, and their sister, Barbara Ann, and if he lacked staff at his office, he knew he could count on his family to pick up the slack. Bruce enlisted Jewell to help coach his junior football team; Watson had a picnic for Richard and Bobi at his parents' house at the Atlanta Country Club.

When Bryant arrived at the Jewells' apartment that night, he pushed his way through the crowd standing outside in the spongy Atlanta humidity. Microphones were shoved in his face. 'What is happening, Watson?' Bobi asked him. Bryant asked Jewell to speak to him alone. 'I want to know if you can tell me, without any hesitation at all, if you had anything to do with the bombing,' he said. 'I didn't,' Jewell told him. 'I said, 'I am going to ask you again.' He would not look me in the eye. I said, 'Don't give me this 'sir' shit.' I said, 'Richard, these people want to kill you. I cannot help you unless you tell me the absolute, unequivocal truth.' I was in his face. He said he did not have anything to do with it.' Jewell was bewildered and numb, said Bryant, who left at 10:30 p.m. At midnight, Jewell called him to say, 'They are massing outside the apartment, Watson.'

The next morning, Bryant went from talk show to talk show, starting with NBC. With the notable exception of The New York Times, virtually every newspaper in the country had picked up the A.J.C. story and run it as front-page news. There were 10,000 reporters in Atlanta; the Los Angeles Times would later call the squad bearing down on the Jewells 'a massive strike force … Tora! Tora! Tora!' Bryant was in a daze, but he held his own. 'Is it true that Jewell was at some time ordered to seek psychological counseling?' Bryant Gumbel asked him. 'I know a lot of people that ought to have psychological counseling,' Watson Bryant replied.

By 10 a.m. he was back at the Jewells' apartment, studying a search warrant that had been delivered that day. The F.B.I., Jewell recalled, said that he could not be inside the apartment during the search. Bryant called F.B.I. headquarters: 'What the hell is this? Why can't he be there?' Within an hour, at least 40 members of the F.B.I. had arrived, with dogs. 'There was a physical-evidence team. There was a scientific team. There was a team for the bomb-squad people, and then the A.T.F.… They all had different-color shirts. Light blue for bombs, dark blue for evidence protection, red and yellow.' Bryant could not believe what he was seeing. 'This is like damn Six Flags over Georgia,' he told them.

'I kept saying to Watson, 'I didn't do this.' And he said, 'Hey, kid, I believe you—we are doing what we can.' Jewell was a gun collector. Bryant was sharp with him: 'You get all those guns out of your closets and put them on your bed. We don't want any trouble.'

For seven hours, Jewell sat outside on the staircase in what has become one of the most famous images of last summer. Bryant had to take his daughter, Meredith, to the Olympic equestrian competition, a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for her. As he left, he said, 'Don't do anything stupid. Just shut up and let them do what they have to do.' Hours passed as Jewell sat in the heat. 'Finally I decided I would ask them if I could go in and use the rest room. They said, 'We got the order a couple of hours ago you could come in; you just can't get in our way.' Jewell was told he had to wear rubber socks and gloves in order not to contaminate the site. The Jewell apartment is small—two bedrooms with a bathroom in between, a living room, an alcove dining room that has been turned into a den. As Jewell sat on the sofa, he thought he heard a crash in his bedroom. 'I thought my CD player was on the floor, and I said, 'What are you-all tearing up?' and they said, 'You can't go in there right now; we are searching.' I said, 'I want to know what you-all just broke.' One search warrant listed some 200 items the F.B.I. could confiscate, including 'magazines, books … and photographs which would include descriptive information such as telephone numbers, addresses, affiliations and contact points of individuals involved in a conspiracy to manufacture, transport and … detonate … the explosive device used in the bombing at the Olympic Centennial Park on July 27, 1996.'

'They had all my pictures, all the stuff that was in the drawers. My personal things. How would you like to know that 12 different guys had been in your underwear, laid it out on the floor, probably walked on it and then folded it back up like nothing ever happened and put it in your drawer? So then Mom got to go and watch it on TV: 'Live from the Jewell house, the search continues.… We are expecting an arrest any minute.'

When Bobi Jewell returned home, the apartment appeared neat, until she walked into her kitchen. She looked down at her counters, where all her condiments, dog biscuits, spices, and crackers had been taken out of their Tupperware containers and placed in Ziploc bags. She began to cry. And then she went into the bedroom and 'immediately started washing clothes,' Jewell said.

Driving home from the equestrian events, Bryant heard the live coverage of the search on the radio. 'Why are you helping this guy if he's guilty?' Meredith asked.

The next morning, Bryant received a copy of the F.B.I. inventory of articles confiscated in the apartment. On the list he was stunned to see 'one hollowed-out hand grenade, ball-shaped' and 'one hollowed-out hand grenade, pinecone-shaped.' 'What the hell is this?' he asked Jewell. 'They were paperweights,' Jewell said. 'I bought them at a military store.' 'Oh, shit,' Bryant said.

For the first few days, the Jewells lived on ham omelettes; a neighbor had brought them half a ham from the Honey Baked Ham Company on Buford Highway. Bobi Jewell had a vacation scheduled, so she remained at home, lying on the bed and 'listening to the ball game if it was on.' For two weeks, she cleaned out her bureau drawers. Richard would spend the day watching CNN or movies such as Backdraft and Midnight Run. 'I would look out the window and see about 150 to 200 press people. Then it would drop to five or six on the hill. They had one person sitting up there at all times with their binoculars.' Richard believed they were being monitored. 'They heard everything that was going on. They were over there with high-intensity zoom lenses. They had people over there who could read lips. They had a sound dish. They could hear everything that we said. They had a person writing down everything we said. I saw them.'

Once, Bobi's cat jumped on the window ledge under the curtain and the photographers began frenetically shooting pictures, believing that one of the Jewells was in the window. Sound trucks and boom microphones prevented the neighbors from getting near the apartment. Three F.B.I. agents were usually sitting near the tiny swimming pool; each time Jewell or his mother left the house, a cavalcade of unmarked cars would follow. Richard soon began to write a speech describing the horror he felt at being falsely accused. He ate grilled-cheese sandwiches, huge pans of lasagna, and can after can of Campbell's tomato soup.

'If my mom and I had something we wanted to talk about that we didn't want anyone to hear, we wrote it on pieces of paper. When she left to go to work the next day, she would take it with her, tear it up, and put it in the trash! That is how I kept my mother informed about what was going on with the case.' The notes were specific: 'What the Justice Department was saying, what my attorneys were hearing through the grapevine that I could tell my mom that was not privileged. It was mainly stuff like 'Keep the faith' and 'Can I borrow $10 for gas in the truck?'

Jewell described how, when his mother would walk out the door, 'they would holler obscenities at her. They would yell, 'Did he do it? Did he blow those people up?' They would yell, 'You should both die.' According to Jewell, 'The cameramen were just trying to get us aggravated so they could get it on-camera. You don't know how hard it is when they are saying stuff about my mother and me.… All she was trying to do was walk her dog. And she cannot do that without hearing that yelling. When someone did that to my mother, I would want to be up on the hill calling the police, because I would want them arrested. I was going to say, 'Mom, tell me which one said that!' And I was going to walk up to that person and introduce myself and say, 'Hi, my name is Richard Jewell. What is yours? Who do you work for? Who is your supervisor?' And I was going to go home and call 911 to get a warrant.'

By disposition, Jewell is a night person, but he would get up early when his mother went back to work and make her breakfast. By 11 a.m. he would be playing Mortal Kombat II and listening to 96 Rock on the radio, where one of his friends is a disc jockey. Four days into his period of captivity, he called the DeKalb County police. He recalled telling a Mr. Brown, 'This is Richard Jewell. I am sure you are aware of my situation over on Buford Highway.' He said, 'Yes, Richard, I know.' I said, 'I just want to tell you my situation. Number one: I did not do this. Number two: I am here and I am not leaving the apartment for any reason at all.' I said that all the press was doing right now was aggravating my mother and disturbing my neighbors, and I would really appreciate it if the neighbors could return to a normal life.'

On Saturday, August 3, as Bryant stared at the F.B.I. agent plucking Jewell's hair, he had already made a decision. 'It was, like, screw it. I had had it.' The next day was the closing ceremony of the Olympics; Bryant imagined that that would be the day the government might choose to arrest Jewell. 'Who is the best criminal lawyer in Georgia?' he asked a state lawyers' association. Within a day, he had brought in Jack Martin, an expert on the federal death penalty and a Harvard law-school graduate with close ties to the local U.S. attorney, Kent Alexander. 'Let me tell you something about myself,' Jewell told him in their first meeting. 'I hate criminal lawyers.' 'Well, Richard,' Martin said, 'I don't much like cops, but sometimes I need one, and this is a time you sure need a criminal lawyer.'

That weekend, watching the Olympic basketball finals, Bryant had an idea: he wanted to be prepared with his own polygraph test of Jewell if the F.B.I. arrested him. From the game, Bryant called a close friend who was a former federal prosecutor. 'Try Richard Rackleff,' he said. 'We worked together on the Walter Moody bombing case.' Rackleff had recently set up a private practice, and he agreed to test Jewell the next day. On Sunday morning, Bryant was up early, unable to sleep. He drove around town, making calls from his cell phone. He dialed 679-9000—the F.B.I. 'This is Watson Bryant. I am going to pick up Richard Jewell. I just want you to know that. I don't have a white Bronco. I don't have a wig, and I don't have cash in my car. We are just going to my office.'

Watson had coordinated an elaborate plan with his brother to dodge reporters; he would use a decoy and snake through a parking garage. Rackleff had been instructed to park blocks from Bryant's office, because his car could be identified easily, since he was well known in Atlanta law enforcement.

When Rackleff sat down with Richard Jewell in the conference room, he later told me, he sensed almost immediately that Jewell was innocent. Rackleff had tested many bombers before, including Walter Moody, who was convicted of killing a federal judge. 'They are strange ducks—they leave their attorneys cold,' Rackleff said. Although no one knew Rackleff was in the building, more than 100 reporters gathered outside to get a look at Jewell. Inside, Jack Martin, Bryant, Nadya Light, and Jewell spent 12 hours in Bryant's office. Rackleff asked Jewell a series of questions, but the test was inconclusive. 'Richard is tormented. He is exploding on the inside,' Rackleff said. While he was testing him, CNN's Art Harris was visible through the window of Bryant's office, but he could not see inside. Bryant was thoroughly deflated, close to despair. 'You have got to try to buck Richard up,' Rackleff told him. 'Who is going to buck me up?' Bryant asked.

‘We are not in missile range of arresting Richard Jewell, but we want him to take our own polygraph,' Kent Alexander told Bryant and Jack Martin in their first meeting on the case. In the meantime, Rackleff had tested Jewell again, and he had passed with 'no deception,' the highest rating. By this time, it was clear that there was no damning evidence against Jewell discovered at the apartment or in his old house in Habersham County.

Alexander was only 38, but he had been groomed for politics in a fancy local family. His father was a senior partner in a good Atlanta law firm, and he had worked as an intern for Senator Sam Nunn. Bryant worried about Alexander's lack of experience, but Alexander told colleagues that he was disturbed by the lack of substantial evidence against Jewell. He was trying to operate with decency, but he was cautious and had to check every detail with Washington.

Bryant, however, didn't trust Alexander; he had had a bad experience with Alexander's predecessor. In 1990, Bryant had almost been put out of business in a tussle with the then U.S. attorney. The local Small Business Administration accused a bank Bryant represented of improper use of funds; the bank blamed Bryant, who was brought before a grand jury and over the next two years almost lost his practice. He spent $50,000 defending himself, and Nadya Light had to take another job, but eventually the case was settled with Bryant's agreeing not to do business with the S.B.A. for 18 months. Bryant had always felt that he had been manhandled by the office. 'I learned everything I needed to know about dealing with this office in 1990,' Bryant recalled telling Alexander. 'No polygraph for Richard.'

At the meeting, Alexander told Bryant and Martin, 'This is all off-the-record. This is a request that is strictly confidential.' Weeks later, Louis Freeh came to town to address a breakfast of former F.B.I. agents. Almost immediately, the polygraph request was reported on CNN. 'Kent, I thought we had an agreement,' Bryant told him. 'I cannot control Washington,' Alexander said.

When two of the bomb-blast victims sued Richard Jewell, Bryant brought in Wood and Grant to handle the civil litigation. Martin opposed the move. He believed in the cone of silence: 'Circle the wagons and don't speak.' He said that Wood and Grant had a different perspective: Attack, attack, and if you give any quarter, it is a sign of weakness. Martin had been reassured in private by Kent Alexander that Jewell was not in any immediate danger of being arrested, but the team disagreed about press tactics. Martin worked through the Atlanta-establishment back channels; Lin Wood was a rhetoric man. He favored 'one big newsbreak a week.' 'You know who wrote the book Masters of Deceit? J. Edgar Hoover! And that was about the Communist Party in America. So now they have gone from masters of investigation to masters of deceit!' he would routinely tell reporters who called.

Three days after Wood and Grant surfaced as the two new civil lawyers, a Ford van with a tinted bubble-shaped window appeared on the top level of the Macy's parking garage which faced the conference-room windows of their offices. According to Wood, the van did not move for 10 days. 'We used to sit there and wave at it.' Then the lawyers placed a camera in the window, and the next day the vehicle was gone. 'For sure that van had laser sound-detecting equipment,' Wood said.

Jewell was annoyed that press descriptions of him always emphasized his 'overzealousness'; he considers himself a man of details. Often, when he's watching movies at home, he freeze-frames in order to study props in scenes. The second weekend he was considered a suspect, he told me, 'I walked in and I noticed white powder all over the telephone table in the conference room.' It was a Saturday morning, and Jewell had been with his lawyers until late the night before. He told me he was convinced that the F.B.I. 'had lifted a ceiling tile,' and that the white powder was 'dust that came down.' Bryant and Jewell made light of it and did not sweep their phones, believing that any tap the F.B.I. would use would be of a laser or satellite variety and impossible to trace. 'In the beginning of every conversation, Watson would curse for about a minute and tell them what lowlives they were. And then he would say, 'By the way, this is Richard's lawyer. Y'all can cut your tape players off,' Jewell said. 'I would call them dirty scumbags,' said Bryant. But the local U.S. attorney, Kent Alexander, insisted that their phones were not tapped. 'There are no wiretap warrants,' he said.

Suspicious package procedure

The F.B.I. did turn up one bit of potentially troublesome evidence in the Jewells' apartment—fragments of a fence that had been blown up in the explosion. After a telephone conversation with Watson Bryant, Kathy Scruggs quoted him saying, 'Yes, he did have a sample of the blown-up bomb.' Bryant accused her of egregiously misquoting him. He remembered saying to her, 'Yes, Richard had souvenirs of the bombing.' Scruggs had not taped their conversation. 'She cut the 'ing' off of 'bomb,' Bryant later told me, but Scruggs strongly denies this. The day the story broke, Bryant criticized Scruggs on local radio. That afternoon she appeared at his office to attempt to clear up the misunderstanding. 'I don't like your reporting,' Bryant recalled telling her. 'I'm human, too,' she said. The next day, Ron Martz inserted a quote from Bryant in an unrelated news story: 'Oh, man, it's not even a scrap of the bomb—it's a piece of damned fence, for God's sake.' But the quote would have little impact. Scruggs's version had been picked up; gathering force, it was eventually related by Bill Press on Crossfire on the evening of October 28: 'The guy was seen with a homemade bomb at his home a few days before.' (The next day CNN would be forced to apologize for the mistake.)

By this time Bryant had grown enraged by the media coverage. The New York Post had called Jewell 'a Village Rambo' and 'a fat, failed former sheriff's deputy.' Jay Leno had said that Jewell 'had a scary resemblance to the guy who whacked Nancy Kerrigan,' and asked, 'What is it about the Olympic Games that brings out big fat stupid guys?' The A.J.C.'s star columnist, Dave Kindred, had compared Jewell to serial murderer Wayne Williams: 'Like this one, that suspect was drawn to the blue lights and sirens of police work. Like this one, he became famous in the aftermath of murder.'

Television journalism was also a revelation to Bryant; he felt he had 'landed on Mars,' and spent hours channel-surfing. On CNN, one criminologist said 'it was possible' that Jewell had a hero complex. Bryant told his brother, Bruce, 'I know I am going to sue someone. I just don't know who.' Bruce Bryant searched for Jewell's name on the Internet three weeks into his ordeal and found 10,000 stories. The tone many of the journalists took was accusatory and pre-determined, with a few rare exceptions, such as that of CBS correspondent Jim Stewart. 'Don't jump to any conclusion yet,' he said sharply in a broadcast at the height of the frenzy.

In his first week as Jewell's lawyer, Bryant went to the CNN studio to be interviewed by Larry King. After the broadcast, he was asked to stop in at the office of CNN president Tom Johnson. 'They wanted to know what I thought of their reporting so far.' Art Harris was in the room. 'I turned around and I said to Art Harris, 'Who the hell are you and the rest of the media to make fun of how Richard Jewell and his mother live? Who are you to make fun of working people who live in a $470-a-month apartment? Is there something wrong with that? Who are you to say that he is a weirdo because he lives with his mother?'

According to Jack Martin, the F.B.I. spent weeks on one erroneous early theory—that Richard Jewell was an enraged homosexual cop-hater who had been aided in the bombing by his lover. Jewell had purportedly planted the bomb; the lover then made the 911 phone call warning that it would go off in Centennial Park. The rationale behind this idea was that Jewell was 'mad at the cops and wanted to kill other cops,' Martin told me.

The rumor began at Piedmont College, perhaps invented by several of the students Jewell had turned in for smoking pot, but it had a chilling consequence. In mid-August, three agents appeared at the Curtis Mathes video store in Cornelia, where Chris Simmons, a senior at Piedmont, worked part-time. Simmons, a friend of Jewell's, who was engaged to be married, was a B student, but he displayed the same porcine blankness as Jewell and spoke in a slow drawl. He had a deep distrust of the government and carried a card in his pocket that read: christopher dwayne simmons—campaign support for conservative candidates.

The agents questioned Simmons in the store for one and a half hours. 'They asked me if I was a homosexual. They asked me if I had accessed the Internet.… They later wanted to wire me. They said, 'If he is really a hero, we will find out, and if not, he has killed someone and injured a lot of people.' Simmons was short with the agents and denied everything. They accused him of lying and said they could take him to Atlanta. The agents told someone Simmons had once worked with that Simmons might be involved in the bombing. 'They kept wording questions differently. They kept saying: Do you think Richard Jewell could have done this if he believed that he could get people out in time and nobody would get hurt?' Simmons later called one of the F.B.I. agents and said, 'I hear you don't believe my story.' He recalled their conversation: 'I think you are sugarcoating your answers,' he said. I said, 'Next time I talk with you, it will be with a lawyer.' And he asked me if I was threatening him. Then he hung up on me.' Ultimately, Simmons volunteered to take a polygraph, which he says he passed. 'I was a nervous wreck,' he said. 'I had only seen this on TV.'

What was not known outside a small circle of investigators was how deadly the Centennial Park bomb really was. It was well constructed, with a piece of metal shaped like a V, and inside, it had canisters filled with nails and screws. Jack Martin, who had spent time in Vietnam, compared its construction to that of a claymore mine, a sophisticated and lethal device. The bomb weighed more than 40 pounds. It was 'a shaped charge,' F.B.I. deputy director Weldon Kennedy would announce in December. It could blast out fragments from three separate canisters, but only one of the canisters exploded on July 27. Someone had moved the Alice pack slightly before the bomb detonated, causing most of the shrapnel to shoot into the sky. The composition of the bomb did not suggest the work of an amateur, Kathy Scruggs would ironically later report, after interviewing an A.T.F. chemist.

As the weeks went by, Richard Jewell withdrew into a state of psychological limbo; he began to try to analyze what the agents might think of his behavior within the small apartment. 'I would be watching a spy show on TV or something like a John Wayne movie. Someone would be talking about blowing something up, and I would think to myself, My God, that is going to sound really bad if they think I am listening to that.' He worried that 'they would think I was some kind of a nut,' and often, when he could not sleep, he would find himself consciously switching to exercise videos and soap operas.

Over Labor Day weekend, he drove up to Habersham County for a picnic with his ex-girlfriend's family, the Chastains. As usual, three F.B.I. cars followed him, but he had gotten adept at picking out the unmarked vehicles. As Jewell drove into town, he noticed that white ribbons hung from hundreds of trees; the Chastains had organized a campaign in his behalf. On the way home, Jewell drove with his friend Dave Dutchess. For the first time, he did not see an F.B.I. car following him, but he noticed an airplane flying low overhead. He drove another 20 miles, and the plane was still on him. 'I said, 'Dave, do you think the F.B.I. would be following us in an airplane? It wouldn't be that hard to do, if they put some kind of beeper on the car.' The plane followed them through Gainesville all the way to Atlanta—an hour's drive. 'Just to make sure, we got off on an exit ramp and went about five miles back north. And I got out and took a picture. They followed us all the way back to the apartment! And they circled the apartment for about 15 minutes, until the F.B.I. car showed back up. I got very emotional. My cheeks got beet red. And Mom came home and said, 'What is going on? What is the matter?' It just destroyed the whole day.'

On September 2, Dave Dutchess and his fiancée, Beatty, were driving to their house in Tennessee. It was raining hard, and they noticed they were being followed by several F.B.I. cars. The storm grew worse, and they stopped at a hotel for the night. The next day, while getting coffee at a McDonald's, they were surrounded by F.B.I. agents. 'We just want to talk to you. We are trying to be discreet.' One agent, Dutchess recalled, spoke into his radio: 'We have the suspect in hand.' As they walked back toward their car, Dutchess said to Beatty, 'They think I am his accomplice. I heard on the news they were looking for his accomplice!'

After the interview, which lasted several hours, Dutchess spoke to Watson Bryant. 'What did they ask you that concerns you?' Bryant asked him. 'Well, I decided that I had to tell them the truth. Me and one of my friends used to set off pipe bombs for fun,' Dutchess told him. 'What?' Bryant exclaimed, incredulous. 'Yeah, I told them we liked to throw pipe bombs down gopher holes when we lived out in West Virginia.'

'Did Richard know this friend?' Bryant asked apprehensively. 'Hell, no. He never met him,' Dutchess said, but Bryant knew that this could prolong the F.B.I.'s investigation perhaps by months. 'I hung up and I was thinking, I cannot believe that I even know anyone who throws pipe bombs into gopher holes.'

As part of their strategy, Wood and Grant decided to mount a strong counterattack against the government. Wayne Grant had come up with the idea: Bobi Jewell should hold a press conference during the Democratic convention and make a direct plea to Bill Clinton. The day before she was to appear, Grant rehearsed her. It was difficult to work with Bobi; she was exhausted and could not stop crying. Confined under siege for almost a month, she could not see an end to it, since every day brought a new humiliation. The resident manager had threatened to take away their lease, and the manager's son was out selling pictures he took of them. A close friend from church was dying, Bobi said, and Richard could not go to see him, because of the swarm of F.B.I. agents and reporters who followed him everywhere. All of it came out in a rush in the conference room with Wayne Grant: Bobi had even had to give Bryant and Nadya Light the Olympic-basketball tickets she had won as colleague of the year, and every night she and her son were stuck together, staring at each other across the kitchen table. They were often irritable, and Richard sometimes lost his temper. 'Mother, just shut up,' he would tell her when she nagged him about the case. Then, Bobi later recalled, she would go into her bedroom and lie on the four-poster bed hoping that the photographers who rented an apartment across the way for $1,000 a day had no way of knowing what was going on.

Grant kept careful notes on the session. Bobi was terrified about appearing in front of cameras. She sobbed and told him, 'If I go on TV Monday, I'll be embarrassed. It will be, like, whenever I go anywhere, people will be looking at me: 'Did he do it or didn't he do it?'

'If you talked to the person who is in charge of the investigation, what would you say?' Grant asked her calmly. Bobi's voice was halting, but she was firm: 'He is innocent. Clear his name and let us get back to a life that is normal.'

A few weeks later, Wayne Grant went to a party for a Bar Mitzvah, and a guest cornered him. She asked him if he had told Bobi Jewell to cry at the end of her press conference, and then added coldly, 'Nice touch.'

The lawyers' strategy worked: after Bobi's press conference, the Jewells were deluged with interview requests. Bryant often received 100 phone calls a day. Bobi soon developed a system: letters from Oprah Winfrey, Sally Jessy Raphaël, and TV producers were stacked on the console in the living room; flowers and baskets of Godiva chocolates and cheese and crackers from the networks were sent to the offices of Wood & Grant and then on to a children's hospital.

At the U.S. Attorney's Office, it had become increasingly clear to Kent Alexander that something had to be done about Richard Jewell. Janet Reno had seen Bobi Jewell on TV and was moved by her sincerity. Privately, Reno and Deputy Attorney General Jamie Gorelick were said to be concerned about the heavy-handed tactics of the F.B.I. 'The case had become a total embarrassment,' a Justice Department official told me, but Alexander was in a complicated situation. He was working closely with the F.B.I., and there was no sign that the bureau was ready to let go, despite growing consternation among the local agents that the Washington command center had mishandled the case. And there was another problem: Alexander did not trust Lin Wood.

By late September, there was a tremendous strain within the team Bryant had hastily assembled. The other lawyers accused Jack Martin of cutting private deals with his friend Kent Alexander, pulling focus, and not being tough enough. For his part, Alexander, according to Martin, admired Bryant even though he believed he was a loose cannon, but he was fed up with Lin Wood.

'Alexander would say something fairly candid to me, and I would report it to the attorneys, and the next day he would see it on TV,' said Jack Martin. 'Alexander had checked out Lin, and he knew that he was a take-no-prisoners guy.' The lawyers often argued among themselves. Wood insisted on a full-blowout press-attack strategy. Bryant had mastered his sound bite: 'The F.B.I. is a 500-pound gorilla who will kick the shit out of anyone.' Martin wanted the lawyers to ease up on the hyperbole: 'I would say, 'We do not need to do this.' And Lin would say, 'Let's go public with this.' He was manic about it.' In one argument, Wood told him, 'Goddamn it, Martin, you're like my ex-wives. There isn't anything you can say I won't object to.'

There was an atmosphere of extreme apprehension between Bryant and Jewell as they drove to F.B.I. headquarters on the afternoon of October 6. They were on their way to what would seemingly be a session with conclusional overtones, but Jewell was worried: What if this meeting was a trick? It was difficult to believe that the bureau was really ending its two-month-long investigation into his life. For weeks, Jack Martin and Bryant had been going back and forth with Kent Alexander. Finally, Jewell had agreed to an unusual suggestion: if he submitted to a lengthy voluntary interview with the bureau, and if Division 5 was satisfied, then perhaps the Justice Department could issue a letter publicly stating that he was no longer a suspect. Jewell tried to imagine the questions he would be asked. 'I wanted to look at everything from their angle,' he told me, 'trying to assess it and reassess it in my head.'

Kent Alexander had set a firm ground rule: Only one lawyer representing Jewell could be in the room. It had been agreed that Jack Martin, the criminal specialist, would be the man, which enraged Lin Wood. 'You could really see how these guys did not like each other,' Jewell said.

'I am not comfortable with the one-lawyer agreement,' Wood told John Davis, Kent Alexander's second-in-command, when they were assembled. 'We have an agreement. If you attempt to renegotiate it, I will have egg on my face,' Davis said, adding, 'You are not a man of your word.' With that, Wood recalled, he rose from his chair and started screaming, 'You are not going to say that to me, you son of a bitch!' Kent Alexander interrupted, saying, 'This is deteriorating. We aim to stop this. Let's just regroup.'

When Jewell, Davis, and Martin finally sat down for the interview, Larry Landers, a special agent with the G.B.I., and F.B.I. special agent Bill Lewis had lists of questions with blank space for answers in front of them. On the wall of the windowless room, there were extensive aerial photographs of the park and, as a prop, an actual park bench was later brought in. Martin believed that the agents intended to resolve areas in the affidavits and other questions: Had Richard ever accessed Candyman's Candyland for information on the Anarchists' Cookbook? Had Richard picked up any pieces of pipe when the park was under construction? Had he told anyone, 'Take my picture now, because I am going to be famous'? None of this had happened, Jewell said. All he could remember telling someone was that he was off to Atlanta and 'going to be in that mess down there,' meaning the traffic jams. They pressed him about seemingly inconsistent statements he had made on the morning of the bombing: Why had he told Agent Poor everything was normal when he checked the perimeter of the fence? Jewell explained that he had been walking the 'inside of the fence.' He once again explained that he had wanted to work the sound-and-light tower so that he could watch the entertainment; he had arranged for his mother to hear Kenny Rogers four days before the explosion.

The area, he told Landers, was 'a sweet site' and a great place to look at girls. During a break, Martin asked about all his references to women. Jewell said he wanted them to know he wasn't gay. On several occasions, Landers became annoyed: Why couldn't Jewell pin down the times? Had he seen the drunks on the bench between 10:30 and 11 or between 11 and 11:30? Why hadn't he looked at his watch? Jewell later recalled, 'I said, 'I don't go through my life looking at my watch. I don't care about time. When the bomb went off, I did not look at my watch.' They were wanting to know what time I went to the bathroom and stuff like that. When you have the runs, you are not really concerned about what time it is. You are concerned with getting to the bathroom.'

On the day after the F.B.I. meeting, Jack Martin dictated a 27-page account of everything that had been said during the six-hour interview. In the last moments, Davis said, 'he wanted to give Richard the opportunity once and for all to say that he didn't do it.' Jewell, Martin wrote, 'unequivocally and fortunately said that he had nothing to do with the bomb and didn't know anything about the bomb and if he did he would be the first to deliver the bastard to their door.' When Martin walked out, he thought to himself, This really was a formality. They had nothing.

In November a rumor swept through the newsroom of The A.J.C. that Cox newspaper executives were rethinking their news policies. According to one reporter, 'The sloppiness of the Jewell reporting and the lack of sources was the last straw.' A reporter named Carrie Teegardin was assigned to write a piece examining how the media spotlight was turned on Richard Jewell. In large part, her article wound up being an examination of the role of The A.J.C. After Wood and Grant threatened to sue, the article was killed. 'We didn't get through the editing of it,' John Walter said. 'The Jewells' attorney began saying, 'We're thinking lawsuit' … and that made us more cautious.' Meanwhile, Lin Wood and Wayne Grant were busy holding meetings with lawyers from NBC and Piedmont College. At NBC, Tom Brokaw's carelessness reportedly cost the network more than $500,000 to settle Jewell's claims, although Jewell's lawyers would not confirm a figure. brokaw goofed and nbc paid, the New York Daily News would later headline. In talks with Ray Cleere, the figure of $450,000 by way of settlement was first suggested, then withdrawn when Piedmont College learned that it had insurance. 'This will cost them millions now,' Lin Wood believes.

On one occasion I asked Richard Jewell if he had any theories about who might have placed the bomb. Jewell said he had popped 'two or three theories off the top of my head' on the night he was interviewed by the F.B.I. 'I have gone over that night hundreds of times in my head. You try to think, What type of person would do that? I know it is someone who wanted to hurt people. It is someone who is sick. I hope they find him so he can get the help he needs. Because I am totally torn up about what happened. Every day I think about it, and I will think about it for the rest of my life.'

Jewell often speaks with Bryant three times a day. As Jewell searches for a new job, he hangs around Bryant's office, and he recently studied handwriting analysis at the police academy. He has been offered several security jobs with Georgia companies, but he is hoping he will be hired as a Cobb County deputy. In the meantime, Bryant, Wood, and Grant have become sought-after speakers on the First Amendment.

At F.B.I. headquarters in late October, Bobi Jewell broke down and cried as she identified their possessions—the Disney tapes, the Tupperware, Richard's AT&T uniforms, address books. It was a tableau of ordinary middle-class life, laid out on brown paper on a long conference-room table. 'I just don't fucking believe this,' Watson Bryant said angrily as he packed Bobi's videos into packing crates. 'The agents tried to shake my hand,' Bobi told me. 'I wouldn't touch them.' It took 10 hours to remove their possessions, Bobi recalled, and four minutes to return them.

The F.B.I. is working on a new and elaborate theory of who did place the bomb in Centennial Park. There is an informed opinion that the backpack discovered a week earlier had in fact been a test run to check F.B.I. procedures, and that the bomber—perhaps a member of a militia group—was quite experienced and had struck before. After a torrent of criticism in the press, Louis Freeh announced that the F.B.I. had arrested Harold Nicholson, an alleged spy for Russia, and he used the opportunity to appear on the Today show and Good Morning America, hyping his role in what was a minor arrest, according to one former F.B.I. agent.

In Australia in November, Bill Clinton was asked about his campaign contributions from Indonesia. 'One of the things I would urge you to do, remembering what happened to Mr. Jewell in Atlanta, remembering what has happened to so many of the accusations … that have been made against me that turned out to be totally baseless, I just think that we ought to … get the facts out.' When Jewell learned of his comment, he pulled up the transcript from the Internet and became angry: 'The president is just using me, like everyone else.'

What rights does a private citizen have against the government? The legal precedent for suing the F.B.I., Bivens v. Six Unknown Agents, focuses on the behavior of individual agents. Wood believes that Jewell has a strong case against Johnson and Rosario. When Wood learned of Colonel Ressler, he hired him as a possible trial expert. In December, the F.B.I. announced that it would pay up to $500,000 to anyone who could lead it to the Olympic Park bomber.

As Jewell and I drove back from Habersham County in November, he went over the early-morning hours of July 27: 'I remember all of the people who were my responsibility. I remember the guys' faces who were flying through the air. I remember people screaming. The sirens going off. I don't think I will ever forget any of that. You just kind of wish sometimes. You think, Could I have done something else? … What if we only had five more minutes? Then maybe nobody would have been hurt. But you are what-if-ing. I have been over it a thousand times. I think we could not have done it any better. I think that is something I will always be wondering.'

He said he was not sure if he would ever get a job in law enforcement again, particularly since he had been held up as a cartoon figure. On the day of Jewell's exoneration, Jay Leno apologized for having called him a Unadoofus, and said, 'If Jewell wins his lawsuit with NBC, he will be my new boss.' He later said that this was 'the greatest week in trailer-park history.' The Atlanta radio station 96 Rock had put billboards of Jewell all over town; 'Freebird,' they said, a reference to the Lynyrd Skynyrd song. Jewell would later file suit against the station, but the billboard's message was clear. Jewell knows that for many people in America there will perhaps always be a subtle doubt: What if, after all, Richard Jewell really did do it? What if the government let him go simply because it could not make its case? Then he becomes not the innocent Richard Jewell, but the Richard Jewell who may be innocent. 'You don't get back what you were originally,' he told me. 'I don't think I will ever get that back. The first three days, I was supposedly their hero—the person who saves lives. They don't refer to me that way anymore. Now I am the Olympic Park bombing suspect. That's the guy they thought did it.'

Marie Brenner is *Vanity Fair'*s writer-at-large.

The Lying Game (season 1)
Country of originUnited States
No. of episodes20
Release
Original networkABC Family
Original releaseAugust 15, 2011 –
March 5, 2012
Season chronology
Next
Season 2
List of The Lying Game episodes
Brooks Buford Suspicious Package Found

The first season of The Lying Game, based on the book series of the same name by Sara Shepard. The series premiered on August 15, 2011[1] and concluded on March 5, 2012 on ABC Family. It follows long-lost twins Emma Becker and Sutton Mercer. Separated under mysterious circumstances, Sutton was adopted by the wealthy Mercer family in Phoenix, while Emma grew up in the foster system. When the twins reunite as teenagers, they keep it a secret. While Sutton goes in search of the truth, Emma takes over her life and discovers more secrets and lies than she could have imagined.

It premiered to 1.39 million viewers and the summer finale accumulated 1.28 million viewers. The Lying Game went on hiatus and returned with its winter premiere on January 5, 2012, and has hit its series high with 1.8 million viewers and has continued for three consecutive weeks.

  • 1Cast and characters

Cast and characters[edit]

Main cast[edit]

  • Alexandra Chando as Emma Becker and Sutton Mercer
  • Andy Buckley as Ted Mercer
  • Allie Gonino as Laurel Mercer
  • Alice Greczyn as Madeline 'Mads' Rybak
  • Sharon Pierre-Louis as Nisha Randall[a]
  • Kirsten Prout as Charlotte 'Char' Chamberlin[b]
  • Blair Redford as Ethan Whitehorse
  • Helen Slater as Kristin Mercer

Brooks Buford Suspicious Package Found In Nyc

Recurring cast[edit]

  • Adrian Pasdar as Alec Rybak
  • Tyler Christopher as Dan Whitehorse
  • Christian Alexander as Thayer Rybak
  • Randy Wayne as Justin Miller
  • Charisma Carpenter as Annie 'Rebecca' Sewell
  • Ben Elliott as Derek Rogers
  • Adam Brooks as Baz
  • Misha Crosby as Ryan Harwell
  • Rick Malambri as Eduardo Diaz
  • Sydney Barrosse as Phyllis Chamberlin

Guest cast[edit]

  • Stacy Edwards as Annie Hobbs
  • Gil Birmingham as Ben Whitehorse
  • Kenneth Miller as Travis Boyle
  • Dora Madison Burge as Lexi Samuels
  • Jennifer Griffin as Dr. Hughes
  • Yara Martinez as Theresa Lopez
  • Craig Nigh as Officer Harry
  • Katherine Willis as Nancy Rogers

Notes[edit]

  1. ^Sharon Pierre-Louis is credited as a series regular up until episode 10. From episode 11 onwards, she is no longer credited.
  2. ^Kirsten Prout is credited as a series regular up until episode 10. From episode 11 through to episode 12, she is credited as a guest star and episode 13 onwards, she is no longer credited.

Episodes[edit]

No.
overall
No. in
season
TitleDirected byWritten byOriginal air dateU.S. viewers
(millions)
11'Pilot'Mark PiznarskiTeleplay by:Charles Pratt, Jr.August 15, 20111.39[2]
Prior to the events that occurred in the pilot, Emma Becker and Sutton Mercer found out that they were identical twins that were separated at birth. Sutton was adopted by a wealthy family at a young age. Emma was placed in the foster care system her whole life. After her foster brother, Travis, frames her for stealing from her foster mother, Emma goes on the run and decides to meet up with Sutton. Already having leads on their birth parents, Sutton wants to go to Los Angeles and find more information about them, convincing Emma to take her place for the next few days. In Sutton's place, Emma manages to slightly confuse the Mercers (although they don't suspect a thing) and break up with Sutton's cheating 'fake' boyfriend. Along the way, Emma meets Ethan, Sutton's secret boyfriend who soon figures out her secret. After Sutton mysteriously doesn't show up at their scheduled meeting place, they both agree to continue the charade until Sutton returns. Someone breaks into Sutton's room and steals her laptop. A scene is then shown of Sutton, sitting in a car, listening to the radio. The car door suddenly opens and Sutton lets out a gasp.
22'Being Sutton'Wendey StanzlerCharles Pratt, Jr.August 22, 20111.47[3]
With no word from Sutton, Emma must continue to take her place until she returns from Los Angeles. She also learns of 'the lying games', a series of uploaded pranks Sutton and her two best friends used to play. Emma takes dancing lessons from Ethan to take Sutton's place at an upcoming father-daughter dance. Meanwhile, Laurel becomes suspicious of the new-and-improved Sutton and even gets a bit jealous. She later catches Emma with Ethan and assumes that Sutton is involved in a relationship with him. Emma defends Sutton's best friends, including standing up for Char against her over-the-top mother and starts to bond with them. At the dance, Emma (as Sutton) is thrown into a fight with Madeline and her drunk father, resulting in Ethan slamming him against a wall as a way of defending Emma. At home, Sutton's mother finds Emma's cell phone and confusingly answers a call from her foster brother, asking for an 'Emma'. Later, Sutton video-chats Emma, telling her that she has faced a few setbacks in L.A. and has to stay in town for a few more days. Sutton also discovers that Ethan has found out about Emma, whom she had never spoken to him about. As she logs off, it is shown that Sutton is actually working with Thayer, Madeline's brother who's trying to make it in L.A. despite his father's disapproval. Laurel tells her parents about Sutton and Ethan after her father becomes suspicious of him after what happened at the dance and they go upstairs to confront her about it, only to find that Ethan was in her room. At the end of the episode, it is revealed that Madeline's father was behind the theft of Sutton's laptop, meaning that he also has some secrets of his own.
33'Double Dibs'Michael GrossmanStacy RukeyserAugust 29, 20111.31[4]
After the Mercers find out that Sutton is dating Ethan, Emma (as Sutton) suggests that he come for dinner so that they could get to know him better. Ethan reluctantly agrees and they both decide to keep the relationship private. Laurel meets a new guy in town, Justin and quickly falls for him. Later at school, Char also meets Justin in the hallway and 'calls dibs' on him, a term Sutton coined that is used to reserve boys. It is obvious that Justin has feelings for Laurel, but because of Char, Laurel is forced to stepped back and she seeks advice from Sutton, who wouldn't normally be helpful in this type of situation. Meanwhile in Los Angeles, Sutton and Thayer find Ruth Peterson, who was listed as Sutton and Emma's birth mother on their birth certificate and find out that she was paid to sign the papers, telling them that she isn't their real mother. Ruth also lets them know that both Sutton and Emma were adopted into wealthy families before she lost contact with them. They go on to find the Websters, Emma's former adoptive parents. They are then informed that while the Websters did in fact adopt Emma, a woman claiming to be Ruth came back for her and they had to legally hand her over. Sutton and Thayer begin to suspect that the Mercers knew something was going on all along. At the Mercer family dinner, Dan unexpectedly drops by to take Ethan home, saying that it was a family emergency. It turns out that Madeline's father's accomplice had framed Ethan for stealing Sutton's laptop. Because of this, Emma no longer knows who she can trust and begins to doubt her bond with Ethan. When they return to Thayer's place, Sutton and Thayer find out that the house had been broken into and that the laptop had been used. When the screen zooms out, it is revealed that Thayer's father is in L.A. and is spying on them from the yard, indicting that he was the one who had broken in. At Char's party, Justin tells Sutton that he likes Laurel, and Sutton gives him her address since Laurel planned on staying home that night. He later shows up at her door and Laurel agrees to go on a date. Emma goes to apologize to Ethan and they share a romantic moment, although they pull back because Ethan was supposed to be in love with the real Sutton, not Emma. Back at the Mercer house, Sutton video-chats with Emma and shows Emma a picture of her as a baby, with her birth mother, a photo which was given to Sutton by Mr. Webster.
44'Twinsense and Sensibility'David JacksonMark DriscollSeptember 5, 20111.46[5]
During a nightly run, Emma runs into Alec, who seems to have been following her, and he offers her a ride home. Alec tells Ted that he needs to keep an eye on her to prevent her from finding out any sort of information. Meanwhile, Char seems to believe that Sutton, Mads, and herself are drifting apart as best friends: Sutton sides with Laurel when it comes to who should date Justin and Mads is having a secret affair with her ballet instructor without telling her. This sudden paranoia comes from Nisha, who after joining ballet at her tennis coach's request, tries to break up their friendship. Back in L.A., Sutton and Thayer are able to zoom in on the old photograph of Emma and their birth mother and find out that it was taken in rural Fillmore, CA. Emma experiences a nightmare in which she is trapped in an unknown place and is unable to breathe, assuming that she must have been drowning. Sutton, who had also experienced the same nightmare in the past, encourages Emma to tap into her childhood memories, as Sutton thinks that Emma is the key to finding their birth mother. Laurel stages a confession in which she takes the blame for stealing Sutton's laptop as opposed to Ethan, who was to be on trial for the crime, saying that it was to repay Sutton for setting her up with Justin. Later, when Emma meets up with Ethan in the middle of the night, he tries to help her recover her memories to no avail. When Emma sees the sparks from their fire rise into the starry sky, she suddenly remembers that she wasn't drowning in her nightmare at all - she was trapped in a fire when she was young. With this information in hand, Sutton and Thayer are able to locate the burnt home in Fillmore and Emma is able to remember many details of her childhood home, from the swing in the doorway to the stars painted on the ceiling. Sutton then finds the name 'Annie Hobbs' also painted on the ceiling and Emma immediately thinks that it was the name of their mother. Alec and Ted are beginning to get more suspicious of Sutton and it is clear that they are hiding something about Annie and the girls' past, while Kristin seems to not know anything about the situation at all.
55'Over Exposed'Elodie KeeneTamar LaddySeptember 12, 20111.30[6]
As the homecoming dance is approaching, Emma (as Sutton) is pressured to run for homecoming queen. She initially drops out of the race, but after realizing that Char and Mads have done a lot on her campaign, and the fact that it would be too suspicious for her to not go through with it, she reluctantly agrees to run against Nisha. Laurel's boyfriend Justin is also running for homecoming court and she enlists herself as his campaign manager. In L.A., Sutton and Thayer continue the search for Annie, but get a bit discouraged when they find out that there are hundreds of women with the name 'Annie Hobbs' in the United States. When Ted and Emma are going through his old high school photos, he comes across a picture of his younger self, Ted, and a mystery girl and proceeds to tear it out of the album. Ted and Kristin find out that Emma is actually a very talented artist and they begin to wonder if any of her birth parents had the same skills. When Eduardo comes to Mads' house to talk about the status of her relationship, Alec comes home early and she hides him a closet. While in hiding, Eduardo overhears a phone conversation between Alec and an unknown nurse. Alec tells her to watch out for Sutton if she ever comes looking for Annie. Meanwhile, Sutton is clearly upset when Emma informs her that she is running for homecoming queen in her place and reminds her that she will take her life back. When Sutton rants to Ethan about Emma taking over her life, he defends Emma and tells her that she most likely never had the intention of telling the world about their relationship and breaks it off with her. At the homecoming dance, Sutton and Justin win the title of homecoming queen and king. During the king-and-queen dance, Ethan shows up and cuts in, asking Emma for a dance. They then share a kiss in the middle of the dance floor, officially publicizing their relationship. Alec receives a picture message of Mads and Eduardo (most likely from Nisha) and confronts Mads. When she admits that Eduardo was indeed inside their house earlier, he goes to confront him about the phone call that he might have overheard, only to be interrupted by Mads at the door. When Sutton sees the homecoming photos online, she stares at screen in disbelief when she comes across a picture of Emma and Ethan's kiss. As revenge, Sutton begins to make out with Thayer, who obviously had feelings for her despite the fact that she had a boyfriend. Emma finds the photo that Ted hid and figures out that it was a picture of Ted, Alec, and Annie as teenagers. At the end of the episode in an unknown hospital, the girls' mother, Annie, is shown furiously painting a portrait of twin girls, while many other like portraits are seen in the background.
66'Bad Boys Break Hearts'Fred GerberR. Lee Fleming, Jr.September 19, 20111.19[7]
While exchanging 'Annie' information with Sutton, Emma finds out that Sutton has been staying with Thayer in L.A. and suspects that they are romantically involved, although Sutton is technically still dating Ethan. Emma confronts Ethan about the kiss and tells him that they'll never work, as she isn't who she says she is and he is dating her twin sister. Laurel and her parents invite Justin and his parents over for a barbecue, but after he continues to give excuses, Laurel decides to pay his house a visit. It turns out that Justin didn't live at the address he provided to the school and this leads Laurel to investigate what exactly is going on with her boyfriend. Sutton is using Thayer as revenge in L.A. while Thayer continues to pour his feelings out towards her. They find an art gallery that takes contributions from an artist named Annie Hobbs and are convinced that she's the one that they've been looking for. After thinking about what Emma said, Ethan breaks up with Sutton to date her, although to the rest of the world, they're still the same person. Meanwhile, backlash from Madeline and Eduardo's flirtationship continues as Mads finds out that Eduardo quit his choreographing job and is leaving town. She suspects that this has something to do with the conversation that he had with her father, and while Eduardo confirms this, he was sworn to secrecy about what exactly went on. Following Emma (as Sutton)'s suggestion, Laurel drives around Justin's suspected neighborhood and finds out that he's actually a runaway orphan trying to make it through life playing golf. Later, Emma finally decides to tell Ethan about Sutton cheating on him with Thayer, but his reaction wasn't at all what she expected and he breaks up with her for not telling her as soon as she found out. While at Char's house helping her prepare for her date with Derek (Alec's partner-in-crime), Emma sees a picture of Annie on the wall and confronts Phyllis about it, only to have her freak out and tell her that Annie moved to L.A. after Ted and Alec 'broke her heart.' Derek hears this and reports it to Alec. Back in L.A., Thayer is upset that Sutton is still hung over Ethan and tells her that he's leaving for a few days and that she better leave before he comes back. Emma talks to Kristin about Annie and she openly talks about what she knew about her (which was very little), much to Ted's surprise, who was eavesdropping from the hallway. Mads finds out that Eduardo had been in a car accident and is in critical condition, calling Emma (as Sutton) and Char to the hospital for support. Ethan accidentally talks about an 'Emma' in front of Char, leading her to believe that he was cheating on Sutton (which is really Emma) with another girl. At the hospital, all the cards are laid out on the table as Char tells Emma (as Sutton) about Ethan's 'cheating', Ethan arrives to explain the situation to a very confused Char, Thayer is about to blow Sutton & Emma's secret out of anger, and Ethan punches Thayer for getting with Sutton. In the last scene, the real Sutton is shown arriving at Dowinger Clinic, looking for Annie. The receptionist falsely tells her that Annie isn't there (as she was forewarned by Alec) and Sutton goes exploring within the clinic anyway. She finds Annie sitting in her room and as she whispers 'Mom', someone grabs her from behind, to Annie's horror.
77'Escape from Sutton Island'John ScottStacy RukeyserSeptember 26, 20111.06[8]
Sutton has been held hostage at the mental hospital where Annie Hobbs is being kept. Dr. Hughes calls Alec and tells him that she has the 'Sutton Mercer' that he warned her about locked up. Alec then tells her to keep an eye on her because the real Sutton (actually Emma) was in a Phoenix hospital with him. After a series of misunderstandings, Dr. Hughes thinks that Sutton is actually Emma Becker pretending to be Sutton Mercer and doesn't catch on to the fact that they are twins. At the hospital, Mads overhears Emma, Ethan, and Thayer talking about Sutton, which then leads to broken trust between Emma (as Sutton), Mads, and Char. Mads suspects that Emma (as Sutton) has been keeping secrets from her and their friendship is strained when it matters the most. Ethan begins to show signs of jealousy when he sees Emma exchanging search information with Thayer. Emma, however, is not fully convinced that Ethan is completely over Sutton after what happened at the hospital. Alec is getting more and more suspicious of Emma (as Sutton) and tries to keep everyone away from Eduardo, who might know a secret of his or two. Meanwhile, Laurel convinces herself that Justin is 'the one' and wants to take their relationship to the next step, asking her sister for advice (although unlike Sutton, Emma isn't experienced in that field at all). Thayer gets Char to talk to her new boyfriend, Derek (Alec's undercover accomplice), about why he's been exchanging multiple phone calls with Alec. Emma and Thayer hack into Ted's computer to find a password for the hospital doors after visitation hours to hopefully get more information from Eduardo. At the door, Emma runs into Ethan, who won't leave her alone, saying that he's only looking out for her. She also runs into Mads and Char, who demand to know why she's sneaking around, especially with Ethan, who they still think cheated on her with 'Emma.' Eduardo is in a critical state and the girls are forced out of the hospital. Alec had also paid him a visit, allowing him to keep seeing Mads as long as he doesn't say a word about the phone call he overheard. Back at Char's house, Emma (as Sutton) decides to come clean to Mads and Char (to Ethan and Thayer's concern) and tells them that she's been looking for her birth mother and that Alec has been keeping vital information about her. Mads is also shocked to find out that her father paid Eduardo to leave town, leading to his tragic accident, although their important conversation is cut short when Alec walks in to check up on his daughter. At the Dowinger clinic, Sutton gets a male nurse to let her out of her room for 15 minutes to meet Annie. Annie recognizes Sutton and Sutton is eager to ask her questions about their adoption, Ted & Alec, and why she's been in hiding. Annie reveals that either Ted or Alec told her that Emma had died that day in the Fillmore house fire and she had blamed herself all these years, driving her to insanity. When Sutton tells her that Emma was indeed alive and taking her place in Arizona, Annie goes crazy and calls security on a heartbroken Sutton. Ted and Kristin find Laurel in bed with Justin through a phone-tracking device. In the ending scene, Emma is getting dressed for bed when she finds Travis, her foster brother from Las Vegas, in her room and is shocked to find out that he knows about her being a twin.
88'Never Have I Ever'Norman BuckleyMark DriscollOctober 3, 20111.23[9]
Sutton is being held under multiple charges at the Las Vegas Juvenile Detention Center, mostly due to Emma. Madeline finds out that Eduardo has moved to an anonymous hospital. After being exposed by her parents, Laurel convinces them to find Justin a place to stay so that he can stay in Phoenix. Travis wants Emma to help him steal from the Mercers and Emma stalls him with Char's costume jewelry. Ethan tries to make amends with Emma, but she continues to push him away due to Travis being in town. Annie calls Alec from the mental clinic and asks him about Emma, the daughter that she thought she had unintentionally killed. He tells her to drop the situation and that she's living in a better place. At Justin's new living space at the country club, Ted notices a crate of his things and almost looks at it, only to be detoured onto another topic by Justin. Travis continues to make sexual advances towards Emma and one night, Ethan catches Travis kissing Emma. Not knowing who Travis was, Ethan starts to ignore Emma out of jealousy. Meanwhile, Laurel and Emma host a small house party while the Mercers are away at the plastic surgeons convention. Thayer invites Ethan to the party, telling Emma that they need to make up since he thinks they are perfect for one another. Emma reveals her current emotions to Ethan, although he doesn't show that he feels the same way anymore. Laurel, Justin, Char, Derek, Mads, Thayer, Ethan, and Emma all start to play 'Never Have I Ever.' At the convention, Ted meets up with an old high school friend who thinks that Kristin's name is Annie. This raises some red flags for Kristin about her husband. After the game, Char, Derek, Mads, and Thayer all head home, while Laurel leaves with Justin to his place. A slightly drunk Emma makes moves on Ethan, who turns her down. In the middle of the night, Sutton tries to call home from jail, although Emma is too slow to answer and she doesn't want to leave a message. Emma finds Travis lurking outside of the Mercer home and tells her that he found out about the fake jewelry. He almost sexually assaults her, but Ethan manages to knock him out. After telling Ethan about everything that had been going on lately, and it is implied that they have reconciled. Back at home, Kristin becomes obsessed with finding out more about Annie after her name was dropped at the convention and this leads to Ted becoming paranoid about keeping his secrets hidden. Ethan threatens Travis into leaving town. Sutton writes an angry letter back home, telling her parents about Emma taking her place. Emma, Ethan, and Thayer find out that Sutton had been held at the detention center in Las Vegas, but had just been bailed out by an anonymous donor. Justin is shown holding a picture of the Mercer family in his room that he tore out from their family photo album. Annie has run away from the mental clinic. On her release day, Sutton is picked up by Lexi, Emma's best friend, who had mistaken her for Emma. Alec sees all of this from his car across the street and he was most likely the anonymous person who bailed Sutton (presumably Emma) out of the juvenile detention center.
99'Sex, Lies and Hard Knocks High'Joe LazarovR. Lee Fleming, Jr.October 10, 20111.10[10]
Sutton (as Emma) stays with Emma's best friend Lexi in Las Vegas after she is released from jail. She is later aggressively confronted by Emma's former foster mother, Clarice, who was most upset about not receiving any more money after her fostering license was taken away when Emma fled town. Emma and Ethan overhear Ted and Kristen arguing about whether or not to 'tell Sutton the truth.' They then listen in on a phone conversation between Ted and Alec. This prompts Emma to investigate what Kristen might know. Laurel's lies to her parents about her and Justin are exposed and this causes a rift between the four of them until Emma gives her a little advice about family honesty. Alec is unhappy about Derek's growing bond with Char (which was supposed to be fake so he could spy on Sutton) and tells him to break up with her on their tenth day anniversary, which he does to Char's surprise. Emma suspects that Alec had something to do with it. Back in Vegas, Sutton is looking for a way back to Phoenix, but doesn't have any money for a bus ticket. After giving Emma's image a makeover, Sutton catches the attention of some boys at Emma's school and they invite her and Lexi to a casino party. Sutton sees this as an opportunity for a way out. A person named 'Annie' calls Char in Phoenix to talk, but Phyllis grabs the phone before she could say anything. It is revealed that she is Phyllis' younger sister whom she had stopped contact with over the years. When Char tells this to Mads, Derek is shown eavesdropping in the background. He later meets up with Alec and tells him that he'll only tell him what he knows if he could get back with Char. At the casino party, Sutton manages to get the money she needs after a series of 'extremely lucky' rounds of blackjack. The male nurse back at the Dowinger Clinic contacts Sutton to tell her that Annie had gone to find her. In the end, Laurel decides to be honest with her mother, bringing the two together, while Ted lays it down on Justin during a round of golf, leading Justin to believe that Ted isn't the honest, wholesome guy everyone might think he is. Lexi reveals to Sutton that she knew that she wasn't Emma all along and urges her to make up with Emma when she returns to Phoenix, which Sutton is reluctant to do. The letter of secrets that Sutton sent the Mercers during her time in jail arrives in the mail and Emma is able to intercept it before Kristen opens it, saying that she wrote it out of anger, but she doesn't mean it now. She tears it up in front of Kristen, but later tapes it back together and reads it to Ethan. Emma starts thinking about how she'll say goodbye to everyone she'll have to leave, but Ethan promises her that he'll follow her to wherever she'll have to go.
1010'East of Emma'Ron LagomarsinoCharles Pratt, Jr.October 17, 20111.28[11]
It's Emma and Sutton's 17th birthday and the Mercers promise Sutton a day full of festivities. Emma is aware that her time in Phoenix is coming to an end and she wants to come clean to the Mercers about her true identity before she leaves. She starts giving heartfelt goodbyes to Kristin, Ted, and Laurel, who have grown to be like family to her even though she hasn't been honest with them. Sutton arrives in Phoenix just in time for her birthday and her first order of business is to reel Emma in using Ethan as bait. Ethan declares his love for Emma to Sutton, who assumes her sister's identity at the computer. After speaking with Alec, Derek shows up at Char's house to win her back, but before she can respond, the police show up to take Derek into custody after receiving an anonymous tip about him. Char stands up to her mother at the police station when she wants to stay and vouch for Derek, but Alec insists that the two return home. Laurel wants Justin to be her date to Sutton's birthday party, but he is reluctant to face Ted after their last encounter. Emma returns to Sutton's room and finds an alert from Ethan telling her to meet him at the cabin, which was actually written by Sutton as a ploy. Sutton shows up to meet Ethan at the cabin and he assumes that she is Emma. The real Emma walks in just as Sutton and Ethan are making out. The twins have a bitter confrontation as Sutton accuses Emma of stealing her life (although it was Sutton who told Emma to take over her identity in the first place) and Emma defends herself, saying that all she really wanted in Phoenix was to build a relationship with her biological sister. Sutton then storms out and heads to her party to reveal Emma's lies. Emma and Ethan have a fall-out as Emma desperately wants to leave Phoenix before anything else happens and Ethan pushes her to fight for herself and not succumb to what Sutton wants. Emma calls Lexi to tell her how everything turned out and after their conversation, Emma decides to show up at Sutton's party after all. Emma and Ethan declare their love to each other and they wonder why Sutton had yet to arrive since she left the cabin long before they did. It turns out that while Sutton was driving to the party, a mysterious figure popped up from her back seat and shocked Sutton to the point that she had lost control of her vehicle and had driven into a lake. When it is time for Sutton's birthday speech, Emma is fully prepared to reveal herself to Sutton's family and friends, but as she is about to reveal her secret, she notices a strange figure behind one of the outdoor curtains and ends her speech before revealing anything. She heads out to find the mysterious person and Kristin follows her, identifying the person as 'Annie.' The last scene of the episode shows a panicked Sutton drowning with no one in sight.
1111'O Twin, Where Art Thou?'Fred GerberCharles Pratt, Jr.January 2, 20121.76[12]
Back at Sutton's birthday party, Emma (as Sutton) and Kristin come across Char's aunt Annie, who now goes by Rebecca. It appears that Kristin, Ted, and Alec were all familiar with her during their high school days, the men especially. Phyllis is outraged that Char invited Rebecca back to town and ends up with a DUI after she angrily leaves the party drunk. After a talk with Alec, Rebecca asks him to submit a letter that would require Phyllis to spend some time in rehab, leaving Char in her care. Meanwhile, a spare car has gone missing from the Mercer family garage and Emma and Ethan suspect that Sutton had taken it, while Dan and Laurel suspect Emma (as Sutton) and Ethan. Laurel loses the vintage bracelet that Justin had given her. Later, Dan finds the missing car in a lake after a nearby fisherman had spotted it. They open up the car and realize that Sutton wasn't in there, but she had left her purse and cell phone behind. Dan claims that Emma (as Sutton) had taken the car after all and when Emma fails to logically explain what had occurred the night before, Ethan steps in and takes the blame for her, telling Dan that he had taken the car to take Sutton out for a 'birthday joyride.' After Alec gets them out of custody, Dan confronts Ethan about constantly sticking up for Sutton and how she wouldn't do the same for him. Thayer suspects that Ethan had something to do with Sutton's absence and although Emma does not fully believe him, she begins to act cautious around Ethan. Ethan confronts Thayer about his accusations, but Alec breaks up the argument before they get anywhere. Ted is shown to have taken Laurel's bracelet while a very upset Laurel shows up at Justin's place and tells him that she lost it. Justin seems worried when she tells him that she told her family that it was his mother's when they were all looking for it and he tells her that his mother wore the bracelet when she died. Emma brings Ethan and Thayer together at the Mercer house to work out their trust issues, when Kristin brings Emma another birthday present. Thayer is suspicious of the wrapping and prompts Emma to open it. Inside the box was a piece of Sutton's birthday dress that she wore the night she disappeared with a threatening note that read, 'Keep on being Sutton.....or you're next.'
1212'When We Dead Awaken'David JacksonMark DriscollJanuary 9, 20121.50[13]
Ethan and Thayer suspect Sutton of sending Emma the mysterious package and believe that she is playing another one of her 'lying games' to spite Emma. Derek is back at school. While practicing tennis, she meets the tennis scout of Ted's alma mater and they see this as a way of getting Sutton to come forward when she hears that Emma is using her name for personal gain. Justin and Ted continue to be suspicious of one another. Rebecca tries to get custody of Char. Now living in fear of Sutton, Emma almost confesses her identity to Dan, but when Ethan and Emma pull up to his trailer and see his brother in a heated argument with Alec, she (Emma) backs out. Later, Ethan asks Dan about the encounter and he tells Ethan about how Alec bailed him out of a tough situation a long time ago. Meanwhile, Emma is off on the college visit with Ted and seems serious about the idea of going to college and playing tennis, something that seemed a bit out of Sutton's character. Justin breaks up with Laurel, leaving her confused as it came out of the blue. However, she feels that Ted is somehow involved. Emma and Ethan find out that Thayer is off following his own lead on Sutton. Ted and Alec are suspicious of Rebecca's motives. Laurel confronts Justin about what had happened between them, but Justin brushes her off, saying that there wasn't anything else he needed to talk about. Back in his room, an upset Justin kicks his 'special box' and some of the contents spill out, including one of an autopsy report, presumably his mother's. Thayer shows up at Ethan's place and is convinced that Annie Hobbs has killed Sutton. They then head to the Mercer home to break the news to Sutton's family. As the three reflect on their good times with Sutton, Justin is shown burning his box. It also turns out that Sutton isn't dead after all.
1313'Pleased to Meet Me'Joe LazarovR. Lee Fleming, Jr.January 16, 20121.70[14]
Sutton is back and says that someone had tried to kill her on the night of her birthday. Supposedly, Annie Hobbs had followed her that night and saved her from the lake after the suspect fled the scene, taking Sutton back to the motel that she had been staying at and caring for her. Emma believes that Sutton is telling some aspect of the truth, while Ethan and Thayer don't seem to be buying her act. Sutton takes them back to the motel, but Annie has taken off. Sutton is instructed to stay at Ethan's place during the day so that she doesn't run into anybody (since Emma is still pretending to be Sutton at this point because of Sutton's noticeable injury). Nonetheless, Sutton sneaks into the Mercer home to freshen up and play around in her room, but is caught by Kristin. Emma happens to come home and witnesses Sutton disrespecting Kristin, which leads to Emma confronting Sutton about the way she treats the people that care about her. To Emma's surprise, Sutton tells her that after she officially takes her life back, she actually wants Emma to stick around. Meanwhile, Ryan, a proclaimed bad boy who had been kicked out of boarding school returns to Arroyo and seeks Mads' attention, although she is convinced that he never changed. Kristin and Rebecca are planning an annual charity event. When Emma leaves Sutton alone to attend the event, someone breaks into the house, causing Sutton to flee, further puncturing her wound when she hits the window on her way out. She goes to the event to find Emma, Ethan, and Thayer, and as Thayer escorts her away from the party, Kristin finds her and sees her wound. Sutton and Emma later switch places (Emma now officially being herself and Sutton now taking her identity back), seeing as everyone already saw Sutton with a wound. Rebecca encourages Laurel to perform in front of an audience. After the festivities end, Laurel runs into Justin on her way out. He admits that he had been hiding something from her and reluctantly tells her his secret: He says that Ted is responsible for his mother's death, as she was one of his patients. His mother went in for a low-risk appendectomy, but Ted wasn't being careful and was distracted by some news that he had received that night, resulting in her unexpected death. Laurel breaks down after she realizes how much Justin has lied to her and warns him to stay away from her family. Since her charade is now over, Emma leaves during the night, not before seeing Sutton, Ted, and Kristin back together as one happy family.
1414'Black and White and Green All Over'Fred GerberStacy RukeyserJanuary 23, 20121.66[15]
Now stepping back into her old lifestyle, Sutton's personality shift is noticeable among her family members. Sutton doesn't want Emma staying with her, so she (Emma) moves into the Mercer family cabin. Thayer comes by to bring her the basics, plus some comfort food. Emma immediately knows the comfort food is not from Sutton but from Thayer, which he admits to. He asks Emma what she is doing with the laptop. Emma still thinks Thayer's dad had something to do with Sutton nearly drowning in her car on her birthday. Thayer says his dad is many things, but he is not a killer. Ethan wants Emma to run away with him, but she is reluctant to leave her sister behind unprotected. Justin approaches Laurel to apologize, but Laurel is still questioning everything about him. Later, Sutton spills Justin's secret to Ted without Laurel's consent and Ted goes to talk to him, leading to a confrontation that leaves Laurel upset at Justin, Ted, and Sutton. Ethan plans a public breakup with Sutton so that he could leave with Emma without suspicion. Mads encourages her father to take Rebecca as his date to the Black & White Ball and in turn, Rebecca tells her to take a chance with Ryan. Kristin reveals to Laurel that because of what happened with Justin's mother, Ted had lost his residency in L.A., which forced them to relocate to Phoenix. Sutton shows up at the cabin and tries to get Emma to stay, saying that she'll tell her parents about her. Emma isn't easily convinced by Sutton's sudden change of heart, but chooses to believe her, as she has always wanted to be a part of a family. At the ball, Justin shows up for Laurel, but Kristin tells him off. Sutton tries to get Ethan's affection in public and it seems like she might still have feelings for him. Ethan leaves early to be with Emma for the night, while Thayer asks Sutton for a dance. It is later revealed that the reason why Sutton hates Ryan is because they had a fling back in the ninth grade. Alec tells Ted that he'll date Rebecca to keep her from saying anything. Dan shows up to tell Alec that he had found Annie Hobbs lurking near the Mercer home; Sutton has been eavesdropping. Justin tells Laurel that he loves her. Sutton goes to get Emma and walks in on Emma and Ethan's make-out session. She tells them that they need to get to Annie before Alec does so that Emma could finally see her. When they finally meet Annie together, she tells them that she isn't their mother. Her own baby had died at birth and when she heard that a woman was giving up twins (Sutton and Emma) at the same hospital, she wanted one of them and ended up taking Emma. When the girls bring up Alec's name, Annie insists that they are in danger. Kristin thinks Ted is hiding things from her. In the last scene, Rebecca appears to be in the same hospital that Annie is currently being held in.
1515'Dead Man Talking'Larry ShawTamar LaddyJanuary 30, 20121.68[16]
After what they had learned from Annie at the hospital, the group is on the lookout for the person who had tried to kill Sutton. At school, Sutton notices a snake tattoo on Derek's wrist and Ethan immediately questions him, although he doesn't say anything before a teacher breaks them up. Laurel tells the Mercers that she is now happily single, but in reality, she is back in a relationship with Justin. Mads tries to get Sutton to cover for her while she's on another date with Ryan during midterms week, against her father's wishes. It appears that Alec and Rebecca are now in a relationship. Sutton and Ethan wait to confront Derek after class, but learn that he had left school early, adding more suspicion. Sutton, Thayer, and Ethan drive over to Derek's house, only to find his mother, who tells them that Derek had gotten a ride from Dan on the night of the party, after his car supposedly broke down by the lake. Emma offers to temporarily trade places with Sutton, as she is the one that is capable of passing midterms and Sutton wants to find out more about Derek. Baz, a guitarist from the band Laurel had played with during the Black & White Ball, asks her to be a part of the band. Emma (as Sutton) raises suspicion in the Mercer household, as Ted and Kristin try to deal with Sutton's recent unruly behavior. Sutton and Thayer find out that Derek spends a lot of time at a body shop, so Sutton and Ethan go there to confront him. Taking a more aggressive approach than before, Ethan gets Derek to tell his story of what had happened on the night of Sutton's birthday: He was supposed to instruct Sutton to drive to a parking lot and the lake incident was an accident. Derek and Ethan then get in a physical fight, although both don't appear to have any huge injuries. When a car pulls up to the shop, Ethan and Sutton flee the scene. They are then pulled over by a cop, who is a friend of Dan's, for a broken taillight. The next day, Derek is found dead just outside the body shop, due to a serious injury to the head. Arriving at the scene, Dan senses a possible connection between his brother and the victim. While he does believe that Ethan is innocent, he tells him to leave town immediately to avoid any charges. Ethan, Thayer, and Sutton are all confused as to what had happened, and Ethan goes to get Emma so that they could run away together. At Arroyo, Ethan and Emma attempt to leave the building, but they run into the cops at the front door. As they're turning back to the other hallway, Emma trips and breaks a heel while Ethan hides in a closet. As the cops take Emma (as Sutton) for questioning, Ethan slips away. Ultimately, Emma and Thayer are left behind in Phoenix while Ethan and Sutton leave town. In the final moments, Rebecca is shown trying on engagement rings.
1616'Reservation for Two'John ScottMelissa CarterFebruary 6, 20121.41[17]
Emma (as Sutton) is being interrogated by the police after Derek's murder, as Sutton is the only potential witness in the case. Since Emma wasn't actually at the scene, she stumbles on her words while trying to re-enact what had gone on between Ethan and Derek. Alec picks up on this and is suspicious of both Emma (as Sutton) and Dan, who he thinks is trying to hide Ethan (which isn't true). Sutton and Ethan arrive at the reservation that Ethan grew up in. She also meets his father, Ben, who is anything but friendly to the two of them. Sutton and Ethan also warm up to each other again during their time in hiding. Tribal police officers show up at Ben's ranch, looking for Ethan as he is wanted for murder. Ben doesn't rat him out and simply says that he hasn't heard from either of his sons since he kicked them out a while back. He then tells Ethan that he has a week to leave. Emma (as Sutton) is on bad terms with Mads and Ryan, as she is unable to keep up with Sutton's inconsistencies. Emma and Alec have a brief exchange at Derek's funeral regarding the night of the crime when they try to get a read on one another as they both think that the other was involved. Laurel performs with Baz's band for the first time. Ryan tells Mads that Sutton had hit on him at the Black & White Ball. Alec spends the night at Rebecca's. After tensions mount between Emma (as Sutton) and Mads because of what Sutton did, Emma reveals her true identity in order to salvage their friendship, leaving Mads shocked and confused.
1717'No Country for Young Love'Michael GrossmanJustin W. LoFebruary 13, 20121.25[18]
Emma and Thayer update Mads on the twin situation. Alec demands that Dan find Ethan and bring him home as soon as possible, as he is Alec's 'prime suspect.' At the reservation, Sutton and Ethan notice Ben talking to a woman who is supposedly into him, although he never reciprocated those feelings. They invite her over for dinner and while Sutton tries to break the ice at the quiet table, Ben gets up and leaves, saying that he doesn't do small talk. Emma, Mads, and Thayer head off to find a college boy who was involved in drug-dealing with Derek, as they're desperate for any leads on who might've killed him to prove Ethan's innocence. Justin is a bit jealous of all of the time Laurel has been spending with Baz due to music commitments. Meanwhile, Rebecca knows of a music producer than could help Laurel's band produce a demo. While Ted is hesitant at first (presumably because of the tie with Rebecca), Kristin steps in and allows her to do it. Kristin is now more suspicious of her husband as she notices that Ted gets weary whenever Rebecca's name is mentioned. Alec is wondering why Rebecca wants to work close to the Mercers. Too many coincidences have led Emma and Thayer to believe that Alec was involved in the Derek's death, while Mads refuses to believe that her father would be a part of such a thing. Sutton tries to get Ethan to reconcile with his father and Ben ends up apologizing for being so harsh on Ethan all these years. After getting advice from Emma (as Sutton), Laurel decides to break up with Justin. Emma and Thayer interrogate two guys at a fraternity house, the frat leader and a pledge, who might know something and both were at the scene when the murderer killed Derek. The pledge then tells the trio that the murderer was none other than Alec (along with his unknown alibi), but he never told anyone because of Alec's ties to the fraternity. Ted confronts Rebecca about her hanging around his family after Emma and Mads go to ask her questions about Alec. Ted refuses to talk to Kristin about Rebecca and Kristin is tired of all of his lies. Sutton tells Ethan that she loves him and they kiss. The cops find Ethan and arrest him on the charges of murder.
1818'Not Guilty As Charged'Bobby RothMark DriscollFebruary 20, 20121.32[19]
Ethan is taken in at a county jail and Alec reveals that he has a star prosecutor working on Derek's side in the case, as he wants Ethan to be found guilty. Dan contacts his old girlfriend, an attorney, who might be able to help him. Sutton returns from the reservation and Thayer suspects that something had gone on between her and Ethan. Mads is angry at Sutton for hitting on Ryan and for not letting her in on all of the things that had been happening recently. She then tells Sutton that Emma is already a 'friend for life,' which is something that she couldn't say about Sutton at the moment, pushing Sutton to a breaking point when it comes to the comparisons between her and her sister. Laurel is the only Mercer that is supportive of Emma (as Sutton) during this time. Baz tells her that their band got a spot as an alternate at Coachella, but Laurel isn't sure if her parents would let her go. Theresa Lopez, Dan's ex, agrees to take Ethan's case. When she asks about any other possible persons of interest in the case, Emma and Thayer tell her about Alec Rybak, which upsets Mads. Emma (as Sutton) goes to Rebecca for help, but it is uncertain which side she's really on. Ted creates a lot of tension in the household with the three Mercer women. Rebecca starts to question Alec during their dinner date, while a note arrives at the table telling her to 'not trust her date.' Alec is quick to refute all of her questions. Sutton and Emma catch up at the cabin and when Emma goes inside for a moment, Theresa sends her a text saying that she could finally see Ethan in jail. Sutton sees the message and responds to it, making sure to delete it right afterwards to leave Emma clueless. Sutton later shows up at the jailhouse, posing as Emma. Not knowing that it wasn't really Emma, Ethan tells her that Sutton means nothing to him. A distraught Sutton (as Emma) then lies and tells him that she (Emma) slept with Thayer. Rebecca gets sent a picture of Alec preparing to hit Derek with a tire iron at the body shop. Ethan is dismissed from custody due to insufficient evidence. Emma is upset when Ethan doesn't come up to her after the hearing and that night, Sutton comes to her and claims that she and Ethan had slept together (which was also untrue).
1919'Weekend of Living Dangerously'Joanna KernsR. Lee Fleming, Jr.February 27, 20121.20[20]
Emma and Mads go to confront Ethan about what had happened between him and Sutton at the reservation, but he refuses to speak to her. Dan tells Ethan that Emma (as Sutton) was the only one who stood by his side during the trial, but because of Sutton's lie, Ethan is still mad at Emma. Ted comes home to find Kristin looking through his old files on Justin's case. Emma then confronts Sutton and Sutton wants to pay Emma to leave town. At the end of their argument, Emma tells Sutton that she's going to reveal herself to the Mercers before she goes anywhere. Emma finds Kristin crying in the country club bathroom and tries to comfort her while Sutton looks on. She finds out that Kristin thinks that Ted and Rebecca had an affair. Kristin also wants Emma to accompany Laurel to the Coachella festival. Meanwhile, Mads and Ryan haven't been spending any time together because of her recent involvement with the twins and what happened with Derek. She hints that she thinks her dad is involved and Ryan tells her that she should find out the truth sooner than later. Emma finally catches Ethan and they figure out the truth about Sutton's lies. The group decides to focus on Rebecca and her possible involvement with everything that has been going on. Dan is getting suspicious of Alec. Emma, Laurel, Ethan, and the band are stranded in Buford Falls when their van breaks down. Ted assures Kristin that the phone call he had received the night Justin's mother died was from a doctor and not from Rebecca. It is later revealed in a conversation with Alec that Ted was lying. Theresa and Dan reconnect and it turns out that they had broken up because of Alec. Sutton and Thayer are researching Rebecca and find out that she was once married to a very wealthy man. They call up his residence and his housekeeper picks up. She was close to Rebecca and tells them that Rebecca had longed to return to Phoenix after the divorce, since the 'love of her life' had lived there. Although she never knew his name, the housekeeper also tells them that she kept a locket with his photo in it, which prompts the two to go looking for it. Emma (as Sutton) tells Laurel that she is a virgin and Laurel tries to get her and Ethan together. Right after Mads and Thayer find out that Alec had proposed to Rebecca, Sutton and Thayer find out that the photo in Rebecca's locket was of Ted. Ethan finally admits to Emma that he had kissed Sutton on the ranch and an upset Emma tells him that a part of him will always wish that he could be with Sutton.
2020'Unholy Matrimony'Fred GerberCharles Pratt, Jr. and Stacy RukeyserMarch 5, 20121.24[21]
Emma and Ethan have officially broken up. Thayer questions Rebecca and his father as to why they need to plan a wedding in just two days. Sutton finds out about the breakup and quickly hits on Ethan, although he assures her that his feelings for her are long gone. Kristin runs into Alec and Rebecca and learns about their wedding. She tells Rebecca that she and Ted had 'talked' and that everything was okay, which Rebecca misinterpreted and thought that Ted had finally revealed their secret to her, leaving Kristin confused. Later, Emma shows Kristin the locket that Sutton and Thayer had found. Sutton and Thayer approach Dan and Theresa for help, but Dan tells them to drop the case. Kristin begins distancing herself from Ted since she is now certain that he had lied to her. Emma goes to Thayer for support and he begins to show feelings towards her. During Ted's toast at Alec & Rebecca's dinner, Kristin storms out of the room, with Rebecca close behind. Kristin finds out about the affair, with neither Rebecca nor Ted denying it. She leaves the dinner with Emma (as Sutton) and Laurel by her side. Ethan and Sutton break into Rebecca's house during the dinner, looking for clues. They stumble upon the photo of Alec at the crime scene on her computer. Ted and Alec have a fall-out, with Ted angrily telling Alec that he never had his back - Alec reminds him that Kristin doesn't know 'half the secret.' Ethan wants Emma back, but she says that they're over for good. Emma (as Sutton) reluctantly attends the wedding (without any of the Mercers) to witness a plan that Dan & Thayer had come up with. Laurel shuts the door on a guilty Ted when he decides to come home. Emma (as Sutton) confronts Rebecca right before the wedding, but she insists that Alec was with her the entire night of Derek's murder. Dan and his police crew do a thorough search of Alec's house while the Rybaks are gone and find the murder weapon, a bloody tire iron, in his golf club bag. Alec gets arrested right after he is officially married. Ethan decides to go to the wedding to find Emma, but instead, sees her hugging Thayer. Sutton is shown overlooking the entire event and Rebecca walks in, with Sutton addressing her as 'Mom'. It is later revealed that Sutton and Rebecca had known about each other for some time and had planned for the events to occur.

References[edit]

  1. ^http://thefutoncritic.com/news/2011/07/05/the-drama-and-deception-is-doubled-in-the-new-abc-family-original-series-the-lying-game-premiering-on-monday-august-15th-at-900-pm-et-pt-905321/20110705abcfamily01/
  2. ^Seidman, Robert (August 16, 2011). 'Updated Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars,' Jets-Texans, 'WWE RAW' Top Night + 'Closer,' 'Rizzoli,' 'Warehouse 13' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved August 16, 2011.
  3. ^Seidman, Robert (August 24, 2011). 'Monday Cable: Bears-Giants Preseason Wins + 'WWE RAW,' 'Rizzoli,' 'T.O. Show,' 'Alpha's' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved August 24, 2011.
  4. ^Seidman, Robert (August 30, 2011). 'Monday Cable: 'WWE RAW' Tops Night, 'Ridiculousness,', 'American Chopper,' 'Basketball Wives LA,' 'Carfellas' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved August 30, 2011.
  5. ^Gorman, Bill (September 5, 2011). 'Monday Cable: 'Pawn Stars' Back On Top, 'Kardashians' Finale, 'The Closer,' 'Rizzoli & Isles,' 'WWE RAW' & More - Ratings'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved September 5, 2011.
  6. ^Gorman, Bill (September 13, 2011). 'Monday Cable: 'Monday Night Football' Rules; 'Pawn Stars,' 'The Closer,' 'Rizzoli & Isles,' 'American Pickers' & More'. TV by the Numbers.
  7. ^Seidman, Robert (September 20, 2011). 'Monday Cable: 'Monday Night Football' Tops Cable, But Sheen Roast Sets Records + 'Eureka' Season Finale & More'. TV by the Numbers.
  8. ^Gorman, Bill (September 28, 2011). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Monday Night Football' Huge; WWE RAW, 'Pawn Stars,' 'American Pickers' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved September 28, 2011.
  9. ^Seidman, Robert (October 4, 2011). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Monday Night Football' Shrinks, But Wins; WWE RAW, 'Warehouse 13' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved October 4, 2011.
  10. ^Gorman, Bill (October 11, 2011). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Monday Night Football' Tops; WWE RAW, 'Kardashians,' 'Housewives BH,' Cards/Brewers & More'. TV by the Numbers.
  11. ^Gorman, Bill (October 18, 2011). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Monday Night Football' Tops; WWE RAW, 'American Chopper,' 'Housewives of Beverly Hills,' 'Bad Girls Club' & More'. TV by the Numbers.
  12. ^Gorman, Bill (January 4, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Rose Bowl,' 'Fiesta Bowl' Tops + 'Pawn Stars,' 'American Pickers,' 'WWE RAW' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved January 5, 2012.
  13. ^Gorman, Bill (January 10, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: BCS Championship Down, But On Top + 'Pawn Stars,' 'Pretty Little Liars.' 'T.I. and Tiny,' 'WWE RAW' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved January 10, 2012.
  14. ^Gorman, Bill (January 18, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Back On Top + 'Pretty Little Liars,' 'Being Human,' 'WWE RAW' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved January 18, 2012.
  15. ^Seidman, Robert (January 24, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Rules, 'Pretty Little Liars,' Love & Hip Hop' Rise + 'Being Human,' 'Lost Girl,' 'WWE RAW' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved January 24, 2012.
  16. ^Gorman, Bill (January 31, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Rules + 'Pretty Little Liars,' 'Being Human,' 'Lost Girl,' 'WWE RAW,' 'Housewives BH' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved January 31, 2012.
  17. ^Seidman, Robert (February 7, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Rules + 'Pretty Little Liars,' 'Being Human,' 'WWE RAW,' 'Housewives BH' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved February 7, 2012.
  18. ^Gorman, Bill (February 14, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Leads + 'Pretty Little Liars,' 'Being Human,' 'WWE RAW,' 'Housewives BH' & More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved February 14, 2012.
  19. ^Bibel, Sara (February 22, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Rules Again + 'WWE RAW,' 'T.I. and Tiny,' 'Pretty Little Liars,' 'Being Human' & Much More'. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved February 22, 2012.
  20. ^Kondolojy, Amanda (February 28, 2012). 'Monday Cable Ratings: 'Pawn Stars' Comes Out on Top, Closely Followed by 'WWE RAW''. TV by the Numbers. Retrieved February 28, 2012.
  21. ^'Monday's Cable Ratings: No Stopping 'Pawn Stars' on History'. The Futon Critic. March 6, 2012. Retrieved March 6, 2012.

Suspicious Packages Checklist

Retrieved from 'https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=The_Lying_Game_(season_1)&oldid=906323501'